The US has not remotely lost the ability to launch people in the context you're suggesting (lost knowledge, lost budget, lost political will). Its literally between launch systems.
NASA has failed at how many launch system projects since the Space Shuttle?
Re:Why America Needs India’s Rockets
by sithadmin on Thursday November 03, 2016 @04:46PM
(#12867789)
I'm not sure it counts as 'failing' when programs are under-funded, then de-funded entirely.
That's the point. A budget that looks underfunded to NASA is looks fantastically lavish in the context of ISRO (the Indian counterpart to NASA).
Re:Why America Needs India’s Rockets
by NeutronBoy on Thursday November 03, 2016 @06:22PM
(#12868555)
In a startup failing and iterating is a goal. Why should this be different in a government organisation?
(Assuming you learn from your failures)
If you could before, and can't now, isn't that pretty much a definition of "losing it"?
Re:Why America Needs India’s Rockets
by kerbalspacepro on Thursday November 03, 2016 @02:33PM
(#12866634)
Two.
The US has not remotely lost the ability to launch people in the context you're suggesting (lost knowledge, lost budget, lost political will). Its literally between launch systems. No knowledge or budget has been lost. On top of it, its doing what no other nation seems able to do, spark a space race between corporations with their own goals and cost-cutting measures. That's on top of NASA's incredible record of space science missions and robotic missions in the interim.
As far as the RD-180 issue goes, ULA buys those engines and re-packages them into domestic launch vehicles that create domestic jobs and keep the majority of the profits local. There's a big difference both practically and politically between this and having a foreign company launch your satellites. So India is not being treated that differently here.
That said, RD-180 purchasing is being phased out. The Delta IV is being retired and that only leaves the Atlas V, which I believe is no longer allowed to buy new engines since an earlier sale this year. That's on top of the Pentagon approving $162m to help fund the AR1 and BE-4 engines which will ultimately replace the RD-180 for the ULA.