News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

Tell HN: Review of the free Motorola Droid sent by Google for Google IO

The Good:

- It's free

- As soon as I turned it on and activated it, it offered a software update which made pinch gestures work.

- Google Goggles are awesome.

- Actually all the google apps on this phone are very well done.

- The touch screen is very hard for me to use accurately, but this could be my fault. It seems like clicks don't quite register, etc. I do not have an iPhone though so I may just have to get used to it.

- The soft texture of the touch screen is disconcerting, but I may end up getting used to this too.

- Verizon 3G should be much faster and more reliable than my TMobile 2.5G.

The Bad:

- It's not a Nexus One. I'm sort of over this but not quite.

- Even though I signed in with google, there are two email apps, two calendar apps, etc... One is the google app and one is the "standard" one. How can I delete the non google ones?

- The droid form factor is a bit clunky, about 2x as clunky as my blackberry 8900 and in spite of this the phone feels fragile.

- UI is slightly sluggish compared to an iPhone 3G or Nexus One.

The Test:

1) Will I give up my $60 per month unlimited voice/data service with T-Mobile and switch to Verizon and continue using this phone after the 30 day free trial?

2) Will I find the phone so compelling that I build an app for it? So far my experience with the android SDK has been shock at how long it takes the simulator to boot (which I think needs to be done every time you want to test a fresh build of your app). Fortunately the phone itself boots much faster.

( 4 comments | 5 points | on HN )
Re:Tell HN: Review of the free Motorola Droid sent by Googl... by cpr on Thursday April 22, 2010 @10:01PM (#1287010)
Re: Verizon 3G data. Agreed; my Mifi is a godsend.

Re: touch screen accuracy, it's been pretty well documented that none of the non-Apple hardware vendors have paid enough attention to this issue.

E.g, http://lifehacker.com/5501814/iphone-touchscreen-accuracy-be... .

Re 2): Could this possibly be true? I'd go nuts rebooting either the simulator or the iPad/iPhone just to test a new version. It only takes about 3-5 seconds to recompile, download and start my current app on the iPad hardware.

Re:Tell HN: Review of the free Motorola Droid sent by Googl... by grandalf on Thursday April 22, 2010 @10:30PM (#1287065)
additional notes:

- the phone's screen smudges horrendously compared to my blackberry 8900.

- The app store is awesome, with great apps that are easy to install. The app store seems to have been given tremendous thought.

- I have not really wanted/needed the physical keyboard. Without individual keys it's not really much better than the virtual one, and nowhere near as easy to feel with one's thumbs as the blackberry's.

- I really don't know why Google shipped these instead of Nexus One's... My guess is that these were somehow cheaper to give away... I can't imagine anyone would choose this phone over a Nexus One.

Re:Tell HN: Review of the free Motorola Droid sent by Googl... by elcron on Thursday April 22, 2010 @06:17PM (#1286659)
On 2. You don't have to boot the phone after a fresh build, just load the updated build onto the running simulator.
Re:Tell HN: Review of the free Motorola Droid sent by Googl... by grandalf on Thursday April 22, 2010 @10:27PM (#1287057)
ahh ok, then I will make an app :)