They probably _also_ feel like it's right. This is one of those social problems where both the business need and moral need match up.
My guess is that people who want racial diversity want class diversity, diversity of thought, cultural diversity, etc. These are not exclusive problems. In fact, if we got to a world state where race played no part in someone's job opportunities, I expect it would be easier to tackle the others.
[1]: http://www.mckinsey.com/business-functions/organization/our-...
And the applicability of studies of the value of diversity in an executive team attempting to strategically position themselves in a market to a team building a compiler is questionable to say the least.
In a vacuum, I'd imagine that having likeness between the customer and the developers to be far more effective than general cultural diversity. A team making a compiler is programmers making a tool for programmers, so it's an excellent fit. I could see cultural diversity becoming more effective once you're trying to reach the general public or niche markets.
But if you're hiring your second engineer on the team? Hire the absolute most productive engineer. Even if that turns out to be a white male.
And don't feel guilty.
https://42hire.com/the-big-lie-tech-companies-and-diversity-...
Congratulations, you've exposed yourself as possessing irrational biases and allowing them to influence how you'd hire, while showing no desire to eliminate, overcome or compensate for those biases. As a result you are unqualified to ever make a hiring decision.
No
>Congratulations, you've exposed yourself as possessing irrational biases
That's rich coming from someone who just made a completely biased reading of the parent comment to fuel their narrative.
Because you can't provide that. "Just hire the best" is an excuse for biased interviewing and hiring processes which self-reinforce; you claim to "hire the best" and then actually hire based on your biases and claim those are "the best".
It turns out not to work:
And pretty much every time that's been shown wrong.
How on earth did it imply that?
This idea that there's a group of hidden engineers just waiting to discovered and included, that they just haven't been shown a company that cares, that somehow if we just went to the right unrepresented areas or schools or groups they would be there they'd be waiting to add millions to the bottom line... Just isn't true.
If you're not showing off your skills, putting yourself out there with code, meetups, conferences, then no, you're not one of the best. Engineers can self-delude themselves all day in their cubicle with how clever their code is, but if you're not sharing it with the world then you're not doing enough to be included in the best.
Most of the money is very dumb and extremely prejudiced. Listening to women talk about fundraising is horrifying.
I work in an office full of people who kick ass but wouldn't make it past the phone screen at most "hire the best" places. Their loss is our gain.
One good historical example is labor force inclusion of women. For centuries, women were excluded from most professions. Circa 1970, women got only 10% of law and medicine degrees. They hit parity in the mid-aughts. Are doctors or lawyers making less? No. The expanded pool of applicants means as a society we're getting either more or better doctors and lawyers, so as a society we're wealthier. And things are undeniably fairer. Economic and social incentives coincide.
I don't think this has ever been proven, especially not in a field as technical as software engineering.
For me, the theory's pretty clear. The hard part about software is not the typing; it's the thinking. It's my experience that thought monocultures are less effective, so I always hire for diversity along many axes. I like having somebody with ops experience. Somebody else who loves the details of front-end work. Somebody else who has wrestled with deep optimizations. Young and old, functional and OO, careful and bold, etc, etc. I take as much variety as I can get, because the more diversity you have, the more problems you can spot and solve quickly.
An especially hard part about software is thinking about users. Good developers are always imagining the effect their choices have on the people they serve. But our imagination is limited by our experiences. Our empathy comes most easily for people like the ones we know. The more diverse your team, the more likely you are to spot and solve human problems.
So sure, it's not scientifically proven to be optimum. But the default isn't either. If we only question the things that seem novel, that's just a fancy way of arguing for a sort of generic orthodoxy.
I should point out I can't stop asserting it's true, because I never started doing that. I said "I feel [...] I want [...] I think [...] For me, the theory [is ...]". Did you really not understand I was expressing my educated opinion?
You won't find a lot of studies on this because it's not a politically correct topic. Nobody wants to do the study that confirms you're better off just hiring whoever's the most qualified unless your customer base is dramatically different from your development team.
I also feel like it's a false equivalency to suggest racial / gender diversity is in any way comparable to this:
> I like having somebody with ops experience. Somebody else who loves the details of front-end work. Somebody else who has wrestled with deep optimizations.
Those things actually relate to the work being done.
Taking recent history, America has been enormously successful and prominent, especially in technology. And America, as a nation of immigrants, has unusually high levels of diversity and inclusion. What in modern America qualifies as non-diverse would still historically be very diverse.
> Nobody wants to do the study that [...]
It must be nice to be able to read the minds of thousands of academics around the world. I'd probably use my powers differently, but I guess you have to start somewhere.
> hiring whoever's the most qualified
Yes, I'm hiring the most qualified team for the problems we're tackling.
> I also feel like it's a false equivalency
It's nice when people share their feelings. Do you feel better? If so, good.
That aside, I'm not sure why you think the feelings of J Random Commenter would be relevant to me as compared with my years of experience building and running teams. Given the throwaway account, even you don't appear to take your opinions very seriously.
Not even long history. I'm talking even our modern tech companies, where many were started out of a garage by a few very non-diverse people.
> Taking recent history, America has been enormously successful and prominent, especially in technology. And America, as a nation of immigrants, has unusually high levels of diversity and inclusion. What in modern America qualifies as non-diverse would still historically be very diverse.
I think you're right, although this doesn't make a strong case for diversifying our almost completely white/asian/male technology industry or any company.
> It's nice when people share their feelings. Do you feel better? If so, good.
"I also feel like it's a false equivalency" is the phrase I went with after softening down "your argument is dishonest and misleading," which is itself softened down from the original response of anyone rational watching you compare hiring both front end and back end developers to hiring "diverse" team members.
> That aside, I'm not sure why you think the feelings of J Random Commenter would be relevant to me as compared with my years of experience building and running teams.
Your comment I responded to asked for a contrary assertion. My apologies if I offended you, but I really think it's helpful for people in your position to be exposed to an alternative view. Few are going to honestly respond to things like this in person out of fear of being labeled racist / sexist, but these aren't racist or sexist views and they aren't uncommon.
> Given the throwaway account, even you don't appear to take your opinions very seriously.
I do take them seriously, but it's not prudent to say politically incorrect things on an account linked to your real identity. I apologize if the comment bothered you.
No. No it did not. I asked oldmanjay if, having falsely criticized me for asserting things with evidence, he wanted to make a contrary assertion with evidence. This was a rhetorical device to draw an interlocutor out.
I neither asked for nor wanted an Internet random to offer half-baked, unevidenced pro-racist, pro-sexist waffle, thanks.
> I really think it's helpful for people in your position to be exposed to an alternative view.
Yes, because I never before would have encountered people justifying the status quo by suggesting that racism and sexism don't exist or, if they do, are in fact optimum. Surely, there is nowhere else on the internet I might have been exposed to an "alternate" view. I'm sure nobody on HN has ever taken that position, let alone in response to me. Gosh, thank you for bringing something new into the world.
> but it's not prudent to say politically incorrect things on an account linked to your real identity
My, aren't you the brave one. As we see in the US elections your opinions are indeed politically correct for a notable portion of the American electorate. They have been politically correct for most of American history.
What you're unwilling to do is to have a lot of people, the people you'd rather hang out with, think you an asshole. You lack the courage of your convictions. So instead of being openly pro-racism and pro-sexism, you'll do it quietly. Hoping, I presume, for the moment that the gang in white sheets get enough power that you can finally be "honest".
If you want me to take you seriously, own your words. The internet and HN have a custom of offering a free hood dispenser to anybody wanting to comment. But that you only feel comfortable opining from under a white hood should tell you something. It certainly tells me something.
There's nothing pro-racist or pro-sexist about what I said, but that's the world we live in. Making an argument for hiring the best person for the job is called racist and sexist. This is the cause for anonymity--people like you demonize those you disagree with.
> Yes, because I never before would have encountered people justifying the status quo by suggesting that racism and sexism don't exist or, if they do, are in fact optimum. Surely, there is nowhere else on the internet I might have been exposed to an "alternate" view. I'm sure nobody on HN has ever taken that position, let alone in response to me. Gosh, thank you for bringing something new into the world.
Your frustrated response at someone who would have the audacity to challenge your view reinforce the claim that it doesn't happen enough. It's much easier to sit in an echo chamber where everyone pats themselves on the backs about how progressive they are and how racist and backward everyone else is, but it's hard to step back and examine things rationally when called out on it.
But it's OK! You're under no obligation to respond to my (or anyone else's) comments. You can return to your safe space whenever you'd like.
> My, aren't you the brave one. As we see in the US elections your opinions are indeed politically correct for a notable portion of the American electorate. They have been politically correct for most of American history.
It's irrelevant. I don't want to limit my hiring options to people who agree with me politically.
> What you're unwilling to do is to have a lot of people, the people you'd rather hang out with, think you an asshole. You lack the courage of your convictions. So instead of being openly pro-racism and pro-sexism, you'll do it quietly. Hoping, I presume, for the moment that the gang in white sheets get enough power that you can finally be "honest".
No. I just don't want to be fired or miss out on a job opportunity because of political disagreements with the hiring team. I wouldn't endorse a political candidate on an account linked to my real identity, either. It's not prudent.
> If you want me to take you seriously, own your words. The internet and HN have a custom of offering a free hood dispenser to anybody wanting to comment. But that you only feel comfortable opining from under a white hood should tell you something. It certainly tells me something.
It should tell you that you and the people like you have been successful in demonizing anyone who disagrees with you. That's all.
The problem here is that you're not challenging my views. You're just repeating a generic pro status quo argument, which comes up every time anybody suggests that there might be some better approach than the (historically racist, sexist) status quo. I have seen it a million times.
I'm not frustrated by the argument. I'm frustrated by the zillion buttinskis who aren't willing to take an actual stand, who try to claim they are being apolitical, but somehow only choose to be "apolitical" when jumping in to object to antiracist or antisexist changes to the status quo.
I'm frustrated by the cowardice. It's not clear that you believe in anything but yourself. You'll argue to protect a status quo that benefits you. But you won't dare do it under your own name, because that might not benefit you. You don't want to limit your "hiring options", while you work to retain the limit on hiring options for women and black people.
> the people like you have been successful in demonizing anyone who disagrees with you
I am not interested in demonizing people. But I will happily repudiate the notion that those who aren't white dudes aren't really people, aren't deserving of the same respect, consideration, and privileges that accrue to white men.
> You don't want to limit your "hiring options", while you work to retain the limit on hiring options for women and black people.
I'd hire women and black people for every single position if they're the best for the job. It's amazing how somehow Asian males have a significant presence and we're all the better for it! Somehow they pulled it off without your help, and I'm sure they're proud they didn't need to play the race card or invoke white guilt to get where they are. They're there because they were determined to be the best for their position, and they earned every bit of it.
But yeah, maybe I'm just racist because I don't doubt women or black people's ability to do the same.
If you want to talk about making it easier to account for white privilege, I'm all ears. But equating hiring people based on skillset to doing so based on genitalia or skin color is dishonest. It's condescending to even think we'd buy it. Make an honest argument for hiring someone based on gender / race and we'll take it seriously.
> But I will happily repudiate the notion that those who aren't white dudes aren't really people, aren't deserving of the same respect, consideration, and privileges that accrue to white men.
Nobody said this, and the gap between "people who think we should hire the best person for the job" and "people who think those who aren't white males aren't really people" is colossal.
Nah man. Even a half-honest business person will tell you the business incentive for making and funding diversity goals is about expanding the hiring pool.
The fact it overlaps with a popular social goal is just an added bonus for marketing and internal feel-good. Maybe the businesses are true believers in diversity, or maybe they're cold, calculating, and just hiring the true believers to diversify their business.
It's like when Google lobbies the government and their goals happen to overlap with ends an everyday engineer clued into the topic also likes. They're not doing it out of the goodness of their heart. But they'll make the strong principled argument for it.
This gets to the core of the issue: in a late stage capitalistic society, meaningful social change ONLY happens when it is aligned with business incentives.
Why not?
Should it follow the local area's racial distribution, especially if that is divergent from the national averages?
In any case, one pro-diversity argument is that across cultures and genders lie different ways of looking at the world and looking at problems. This adds more potential good solutions to the discovery space your workers are exploring.
However, I think underlying these movements is that companies desperately do not want to be viewed as socially offensive, to avoid being in the crosshairs of devastating angry mob backlashes.
Of course, there's also something to be said about the lack of diversity in the pool of software engineer candidates, which signals a problem for the industry in general for the same reasons. That's e.g. why tech companies are funding programs so that girls aren't turned off a software career if that's what they fancy.
Those details aside, in general my impression is that the industry isn't currently in any sort of stagnation of opportunities, with employees' salaries racing to the bottom to cling on those opportunities. On the opposite, there seems to be plenty of things still to be done, and not enough hands. If you dump a lot of new good candidates in the pool, they're going to be absorbed right away, even if they're all white American males.
We are infinitely certain of this, which explains many things.
1. That the candidate pool matches the general population.
2. That the company is discriminating against this candidate pool, leading to skewed demographics.
For some reason, assumption (1) seems to be implicitly trusted, and all blame fall to assumption (2) -- that is, that any deviation from the general population is somehow the fault of the company. I would posit that assumption (1) is typically not true. For instance, we know from studies that the STEM candidate pool for women is smaller than the general population, due to university dropout. It is impossible for every STEM company to have a population distribution of women that matches the general population. Reverse applies to, say, nursing or teaching, which have larger-than-expected numbers of women. (I'll leave it to the reader to make their own conclusions about why we aren't reading about diversity problems in such fields.)
Or have you considered the possibility that social conditioning can make a large difference in what hobbies and preferences someone ends up having?
But even if there are first-order biological reasons ("encoded into the Y chromosome"), there could be second-order biological reasons. E.g. women choose when it comes to sex (the underlying biological reason being, men have more time and more chances (more sperm) to make kids, so they can afford to be less picky), so men will put more energy in displaying/becoming a good partner (e.g. by earning more money). I guess it's a similar logic to why murder is immoral - there's no immediate biological reason for it, but the groups where killing in-group members was condoned simply didn't survive.
Historically, most people have been killing each other for resources.
Ultimately, food and water are the most important ones, so there had been historic precedents of cannibalism among groups of people in harsh conditions where resources were very scarce.
There does seem to be some supporting evidence for this theory over social conditioning.
Sex differences in rhesus monkey toy preferences parallel those of children[1]
[1]: http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0018506X08...
[edit] I'm actually rather uncomfortable posting this paper as I don't feel I personally have enough expertise to draw any conclusions from it.
I'm just posting it as it seems to directly address the parent's question.
In a sense we have gone back to believing that the Earth is flat when we deny uncomfortable conclusions based on society's (implicit) pressure.
I didn't want my posting of it to be taken as a statement of a poorly informed opinion one way or another, rather than me feeling pressured by society not to discuss it.
I personally don't have anything objective to contribute to discussion that wouldn't be distracting.
Seriously, go read about stuff like the blind auditions for orchestras (and applications of the same technique to other fields) and how they blew up any notion of meritocratic processes and gender/racial imbalance being purely due to lack of interest or ability from the groups being excluded.
Does it still hold when there is no gatekeeper?
I'm not seeing that many minority or women as entrepreneurs. Can you hypothesize why is that?
For example if the oft cited gender pay gap is really as wide as 23%, where are the all female companies with female CEOs exploiting the market inefficiencies?
Why? Because you haven't read mine. You replied to a strawman.
I was talking about female CEOs, not female employees.
Where are the female Zuckerbergs and Bill Gates' who dropped out of college and went on to build tech empires?
So any "in a highly convenient coincidence, human sexual dimorphism just happens to prevent women being interested in/good at my field of endeavor" argument should at this point probably carry a presumption of incorrectness (and of same for anyone advancing said argument, if not presumption of outright bias/discrimination) until overwhelming evidence is provided in support.
In any case, I think it's worth to look at it and try to solve it, because maybe you end up improving the actual/future employees' life and the company itself.
And possibly race is not the only division to look at, as you say. Class is probably more interesting, but also age, family responsibilities or sexual orientation can reveal practices/attitudes that can be improved.
I agree with you in the cynical thinking and in the motivations of some of the groups pushing for it, but I think that in the long run thinking about the diversity problem and trying to fix it can lead to better outcomes for everybody.
Too many underrepresented groups would be a nicer way of putting it.
> Should it follow the US racial distribution?
Would that not be fairest?
> Since race is only skin deep
It's about institutionalized racism, so race is what we should be looking at.
Besides, your idea wouldn't be that interesting considering how underrepresented women are regardless of race.
Only if everyone wants to do it equally. We haven't had enough experience with non-discrimination yet to figure out if this is the case or not.
>Would that not be fairest?
Why?
Maybe age has turned me into a cynic, you can never know for sure, but this seriously starts to look like an organized campaign to 1/ increase the supply of engineers in the valley 2/ increase competition for access to a limited supply of jobs 3/ maintain engineers as a inexpensive, replaceable and unorganized workforce (in the face of increasing demand).
To address the diversity numbers of Facebook, I wonder what are they exactly suggesting when they mean that it is not "diverse"? At the risk of sounding like a white supremacist (I am Vietnamese) that very much sounds like a code word for "too many white people" or "too many asians". To clear that out and maybe find out that I am mistaken, I want to know with what kind of demographic breakdown would proponents of diversity be pleased. Should it follow the US racial distribution? Or have equal proportions of people from each race?
Finally, I think that a breakdown according to class would be much more interesting than this document. Since race is only skin deep, I do believe that having people from all walks of life would be a better optima than having people of different colors (that are all upper middle class).