Re:Why terrorism doesn’t work (2002) [pdf]
by nailer on Wednesday November 02, 2016 @07:48AM
(#12853758)
Didn't the provisional IRA force the government's hand in the Good Friday Agreement? There's a fairly good chance the Catholic portion of Northern Ireland, which generally favors independence, will overtake the Protestant population which generally favors union with Great Britain. The GFA allows a popular vote on the matter. So by securing a vote, NI will likely go back to Ireland in a generation or two.
There were also immediate wins, particularly dismantling the RUC which performed attacks against civilians and colluded with unionist terror groups.
(disclaimer: I believe attacking civilians is awful and god isn't real)
Re:Why terrorism doesn’t work (2002) [pdf]
by notahacker on Wednesday November 02, 2016 @09:04AM
(#12854228)
The basic principle of self-determination by popular vote was supported by the UK Government and opposed by the paramilitaries and hardline politicians (both the IRA and hardline loyalists) throughout the 1980s.
They could have had something similar to the Good Friday Agreement much earlier had they been willing to pursue that type of settlement by political means earlier.
Depends which movement called the IRA we're talking about and (more generally) what's meant by "terrorism". There's a degree of a difference between the tactical approach of IRA that won the independence of the Irish Free State in the early twentieth century through classic guerrilla warfare tactics aimed at weakening British security forces and making Ireland ungovernable and and some of the more stereotypical terrorist activities carried out by the Provisional IRA in the late twentieth century involving the high profile bombing of city centres with the (wholly unsuccessful) aim of weakening the British public's resolve to continue to support the Union in Northern Ireland.