That’s then writing a dictionary, and it’s fine, but it’s not defining a standard.
As said, the one most important property of a standard is that it simplifies the existing situation, and is stricter than what came before.
The W3C once produced standards, now not anymore. The WHATWG never produced standards.
I mean, we can fucking standardize languages and adapt the way people spell something or the way they use grammatical constructs by law within of only a few years.
If we can do it with natural language, doing it with the web is completely doable. Because languages ARE infinite monkeys with infinite typewriters.
People with your attitude are a big part of why the W3C HTML Working Group failed. It's easy to expound on what Real True Standards should be when you have no real skin in the game. Those with a real stake in the result care about what actually works instead, and have no time for this kind of philosophizing.
When people used to traditional standards complain about WHATWG specs, it's more often for excess precision about edge cases (including error handling on non-conforming content) and resulting lack of implementation freedom. I've never before seen anyone complain about the opposite.
(To be fair, modern W3C specs are much closer to the WHATWG level of precision.)
And for the actually existing web, which is best modeled as infinite monkeys with infinite typewriters, you need this level of exacting precision to achieve actual interoperability.