News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft Concept Graph by ChuckMcM on Wednesday November 02, 2016 @03:35AM (#12852893)
FWIW, I don't think computers will need to think of a thing any more than they need to "learn" that 1 + 1 = 2. When you break down how logic circuits work to the point where you are describing a full adder in gates you can see that 1 and 1 "has" to be 2. And when you start tracing out the n-dimensional graph space of concepts you will see that "understanding" that Oct 13, 1881 is a "date in time" is simply because that is the only concept in the graph near the nodal points.

It is exceedingly challenging to conceptualize n-dimensional topologies given our three dimensional (or four) up bringing, but when you consider that the definition of a dimension is a direction orthogonal to all other dimensions you can think of the orthogonal things that might be on another dimension and topologically connect.

For example, 13 is a number, its a prime, it can be a month day, it can be a street address, Etc. You can think of '13' as a dimension which is orthogonal to all of those other dimensions (numbers, primes, dates, addresses, Etc) such that it spears through them. Now when you see "oct" it also spears through a bunch of alternate dimensions but the only dimensions that both Oct and 13 exist in is the 'date' dimension and maybe the ASCII dimension (13 can be an Octal number). But add the 1881 and the three of them no land pretty solely in the "dates" plane of existence.

The trick is searching the solution space of n-dimensions in finite time. Certainly something a quantum computer might achieve more easily than a Von-neumann machine but given that the dimensional space is nominally parallelizable (at the expense of memory of course) I expect you can get fast enough with enough compute threads.

Another challenge is constructing the concept graph to begin with but there is lots of great research going into combining ontologies with natural language processing in order to build concept graphs. If I were getting a Phd today I'd probably be working on that particular problem.

Re:Microsoft Concept Graph by thewarrior on Wednesday November 02, 2016 @08:02AM (#12853826)
What do you think of learning these things by watching films ?

We have hundreds of thousands of hours of programming right from the Kindergarten level.

Re:Microsoft Concept Graph by ChuckMcM on Wednesday November 02, 2016 @10:45AM (#12855237)
That feels to me like stacking challenges because image interpretation is a challenge on top of concept generation as a challenge.

That said, there is the problem of believing your initial concepts. And, like people, if you start with a bunch of bogus concepts its going to be hard to break free of that and establish concepts more liberally. I think about it as the question of not only establishing the concepts but establishing the validity of the concepts that have been established. In a very sparse concept space your "best match" can be really far off from what someone with a more filled out concept space would consider valid.