Having said that, you seem to be implying that the same standard of evidence should apply to both science and philosophy/religion, which doesn't make sense. For example, trying to use a computer-related analogy, demanding scientific evidence for an afterlife would be like trying to access VM host memory from within a guest: what happens in the host happens outside the realm of the guest, and the guest cannot (or should not be able to, if properly implemented) directly access host memory.
The bottom line is that you cannot prove or disprove philosophy with science.
Other faiths seem to have found workarounds for this problem. Islam, for instance, has no Nicene creed. There's just the "There is no God but God, and Mohammed is his prophet" thing. Instead, Muslims empower their imams to interpret the religion at the local level. This, of course, leads to violent conflict when leaders from different sects disagree with each other.
The progress made by Christianity over the centuries can arguably be credited to the prescriptive tradition shared by almost all of its denominations. Christ supposedly appointed Peter as his vicar on Earth. It seems perilous -- historically, if not spiritually -- to dismiss the importance of that act.