News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Intel-backed Finnish startup has turned laptop design ups... by acdha on Monday October 31, 2016 @10:45AM (#12837160)
Gains:

1. No issues with licensing for third-party components or drivers, which is most of them.

2. Reduced risk of source updates leaking news about new products and features

3. No need to spend time managing an open-source release process, ensuring that sensitive data isn't leaked outside, etc. Just the legal review for release & accepting contributions is not trivial.

4. No support requests from people who installed someone's fork with a bug in it.

5. Perceived less helpful to someone in a country with lax intellectual property enforcement making a knock-off device and undercutting you

No matter how much you like open-source, there are real costs. You can make the argument that outside contributions will balance those out but that's hard for something like this because much of the cost is up front and all of the benefits are hypothetical future contributions and in the case of firmware relatively few people have the skills or interest to contribute. I might make the argument that the fixes you'd get are probably less frequent but higher value (thinking of e.g. sysadmins fixing difficult in-the-wild bugs which aren't easy to reproduce) but that's pure speculation.

There are no comments on this comment yet.