News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Strange Inevitability of Evolution by WalterBright on Sunday October 30, 2016 @07:47PM (#12833254)
A theory makes predictions that can be tested. Creationism is a faith, not a theory, as it makes no predictions.

For example, Einstein's relativity theory predicted that gravity bends light, an effect that had never been observed. Decades later, the theory was confirmed when bent light was detected and the amount of the bend matched the theory's prediction.

Re:The Strange Inevitability of Evolution by TeMPOraL on Sunday October 30, 2016 @08:27PM (#12833435)
I'd say that for a typical religious person, "theory of evolution" as a source of life is akin to saying "Einstein's theory predicted gravity bends light, therefore my sun burn was really caused by a black hole over at Proxima Centauri". There's kind of a huge gap to cover between directly testable predictions and what's trying to be explained. So it boils down to whether or not you believe a complex chain of reasoning made by smart people, and there's plenty of things that can influence what you believe and who you trust.
Re:The Strange Inevitability of Evolution by flukus on Sunday October 30, 2016 @09:58PM (#12833783)
> There's kind of a huge gap to cover between directly testable predictions and what's trying to be explained.

The thing is, evolution is really simple. First there are random mutations, which are directly testable. Your DNA will be slightly wrong from your parents DNA. Secondly, there is environmental selection, also easily testable. Drop a house cat in the middle of the arctic and you'll see how it works, although there are much better (and humane) experiments that have been conducted. The testability is much more accessible to ordinary folk than Einsteins theory will ever be.

The final component is time, which is really what creationist take issue with. That's why you'll see them reject every branch of science except evolution.

Re:The Strange Inevitability of Evolution by SiVal on Sunday October 30, 2016 @10:01PM (#12833794)
Although I tend to agree with you, Walter, most of the time, and I don't disagree here, I'm a little puzzled at why you're making this distinction. When discussing the evolution of humans, it was already a past event before any explanations were even possible, and creationism and evolution are both (in this context) offered as explanations for something that happened in the past, like the Tunguska Event. We can't really make predictions about Tunguska, just figure out what explanation is most likely. For creationism vs evolution of humans, predictions, except maybe about things that haven't been found in the fossil record but will be, don't seem involved. It's not faith vs. theory; it's plausibility of explanation vs. explanation or mechanism vs. mechanism.

But if we're talking about something going forward, which excludes the origin of humans, evolution definitely makes predictions (and creationism has nothing to say, AFAIK). We can see evolution in action with our own eyes in those recent "evolution of drug resistant bacteria" videos, and we can definitely make predictions about that and run cool experiments, but creationism isn't a part of those conversations. It's only about where humans first came from.

I'm not defending creationism (more generally: things that even a human isn't smart enough to do but yet WERE done, were done by being(s) smarter than humans) as an explanation, which I believe was only the most likely until we discovered a clearly superior and powerful explanation, but I'm a little puzzled at the "creationism is faith, evolution is theory" response. Evolution as explanation for the past seems like the same kind of thing as creationism, and creationism is only about explaining the past.

Re:The Strange Inevitability of Evolution by WalterBright on Sunday October 30, 2016 @10:58PM (#12834023)
Evolution predicted many discoveries in the fossil record. Even though they happened in the past, the discovery came after the theory. Evolution has predicted innumerable other discoveries, too, like the tree of hemoglobin molecules matches the tree formed by morphological comparisons.

To my knowledge creationism has never made a prediction, nor has any new discovery confirmed anything about it.