I didn't reject the game theory comment; I merely played the game according to my values.
By adding my downvote to each and every comment in this subthread, I have imposed a cost upon the average user for attempting to game the karma system with uninteresting comments.
My downvotes signal that I would like to see fewer comments of this type. This comment does so more explicitly; I believe the utility I derive from discouraging karma-gaming comments (even those meant as a joke) is worth the risk of up to 10 of my own karma.
I now resign myself to an additional -4 comment. Karma comes, karma goes. I guess it all evens out in the end. Funny that.