News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Can money buy you a higher GPA? by chbarts on Wednesday April 21, 2010 @04:23PM (#1283177)
> What is your evidence for that claim?

Common usage, which you can see as easily as I can. For example, do news agencies typically use FBI or F.B.I.? Do they typically use UN or U.N.?

> That is, what is the evidence that current professional editors are on record as saying that the quoted advice is old-fashioned and not to be regarded?

You again misunderstand the role professional editors (and, by extension, style guides) fill. They enforce what's commonly known as a 'house style', which may be influential outside of a given 'house' (company or newsroom) but is not authoritative in any sense anywhere but that single location. Language is not defined by books: it is described by them.

> (This subthread started, after all, with an HN participant noting that editors were FOLLOWING the quoted rule.)

That comment was deleted before I got to it.

There are no comments on this comment yet.