News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stealth Boat the U.S. Government Won't Buy or Let Be Sold... by cnvogel on Sunday October 30, 2016 @05:47AM (#12828911)
Is it just me, or does $19M sound ridiculously low for building a prototype of a military vessel?

Most larger yachts that are built for rich people seems to cost around this ballpark, and for them I would expect that no new technology has to be integrated from scratch, in to the core design (as in: motors, geometry of the hull). Exceptionally ugly boats, like Venus built for the late Steve Jobs claim to cost $100M!.

With a innovative new concept, I expect a lot of individual systems to be prototyped, scrapped, reworked. Let alone the effort needed for designing this thing. This is a startup with 20 People (17 of them now being layed off) operating for several years building a SHIP.

Anyone having numbers for typical effort/money/time/headcount spent in designing and building novel boats?

Re:Stealth Boat the U.S. Government Won't Buy or Let Be Sold... by madaxe_again on Sunday October 30, 2016 @06:13AM (#12828989)
Sure. My mother and her partner had a 70' motor catamaran built in Chile.

Custom job - designed by marine architect and customer. Custom hull, and mostly off the shelf running gear, big Cummins in each hull etc. Passagemaker, goes anywhere other than ice pack, huge range - they did a Pacific crossing a few years back without a refuel.

It took a team of 20 on/off (they work on a dozen or so boats concurrently), lots of calls and meetings, and cost about $2.5m all said and done. One would assume the shipbuilder made a decent profit. IIRC it didn't require much tweaking after sea trials.

The materials tend to be the cheap bit, it's skilled labour and design that costs you.

Re:Stealth Boat the U.S. Government Won't Buy or Let Be Sold... by semi-extrinsic on Sunday October 30, 2016 @07:25AM (#12829209)
Well, the cost to an employer of 20 qualified engineers working for 3 years should be at least $10M. So you've spent >50% of that budget on just payroll + employee overhead.

So we have $9M left. There's a pair of 2000 shp turboshaft engines, something like the GE T700, costing around $2M total. Probably another $2M on drives and supercavitating propellers. Then there's all sorts of other equipment like radar, navigation, hydraulics etc. with $5M left. So I'm not sure it's entirely unreasonable.

But probably they're reporting a cost that's representative of what these would cost if someone went and ordered 10 of them.

Re:Stealth Boat the U.S. Government Won't Buy or Let Be Sold... by rahrahrah on Sunday October 30, 2016 @02:30PM (#12831400)
Sure, if you got everything right on first try.
Re:Stealth Boat the U.S. Government Won't Buy or Let Be Sold... by gaius on Sunday October 30, 2016 @10:47AM (#12830074)
Is it just me, or does $19M sound ridiculously low for building a prototype of a military vessel?

Only because you've been desensitized by years of F35 budget overruns.

Re:Stealth Boat the U.S. Government Won't Buy or Let Be Sold... by dsfyu404ed on Sunday October 30, 2016 @11:05AM (#12830164)
You underestimate the amount of markup that goes into a yacht. Most of that is in the interior and other stuff the occupants will see. This boat is a fraction of the size and likely got its entire interior from a government auction.

Without all the BigCo overhead you can build single prototypes with much less money.