According to the article, it simply rarely pays up; it's a shame they don't go more into why.
One reason for this turns out to be that if the agency settles, it comes out of their budget, but if the agency loses in the Court of Claims, it comes out of a separate Treasury fund for claims against the Government.
You can say that your product is worth $1bn until you're blue in the face, but there won't be any evidence of that without any buyers.
Reasons cited for control: NS (National Security), MT (Missile Technology), AT (Anti-terror).
However given that the constitution is widely ignored by the US government today, with full support of the court system, it is unlikely that the constitution will protect anyone.
People seem to forget what the constitution is, the Constitution grants government its power, if the constitution is silent on a matter than the government is suppose to be powerless, is not suppose to engage in that activity.
This means a whole host of things the government does, should be unconstitutional, but sadly the courts have interrupted the constitution to include powers it does not contain.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_Clause
They've turned it upside down and made it protect the state instead. The constitution does not grant this power to the state.
I wanted to buy a new rifle stock from the USA, but apparently since it's over US$100, it's a controlled export (firearm component). It's a damn piece of timber with a couple of holes in it!
Apparently I'd need an export certificate to get it out of the USA, which of course requires stacks of paperwork. No issues getting it into New Zealand though, no restrictions at all (I think magazines and receivers are the only parts that require import certificates).
Well, sure, you could argue that, but that argument justifies every rule that exists now or might in the future.
Export controls are there to prevent killing machines getting in the hands of a countries enemies (or potential enemies in the future)
In practice that isn't, umm, practical. Consider the Falklands war - Argentina had Type 42 destroyers sold to them by Britain, and Exocet missiles sold by fellow NATO member France.
1. You live in the US
2. You believe the US government is moral and "good"
3. Any "enemy of the US" is evil
3 assumptions I am not willing to support
It isn't about believing your government is moral or good. Its about understanding that your government is responsible for the safety of citizens, and that your enemies will want to kill you (or at least kill your soldiers).
I would be much happier with US strategy if the discussion always began with metaanalysis of the motivations and origins of a putative enemy, with the focus on social and humanitarian means to prevent the formation of new problems.
But you don't really need to assume any of that. If you just assume that spreading military tech is a net negative, then this is good. I don't support the US's use of drones, but I especially don't want other countries to have drones. I don't support the use of nuclear bombs, but I certainly don't want other countries to have them. Whether the country is good or not, I think advancing military tech is at best neutral, and at worst very, very bad.
Better stop using that GPS as well, and about 1000000000 of other common everyday technology that was created for military reasons.
The internet started as a ARPA research project, the fact that it is used by civilians today is not relevant to the conversation
You stated that "I think advancing military tech is at best neutral, and at worst very, very bad." GPS and the Internet are 2 prime examples of Military Tech has that massively improved the world. Nuclear Power being a 3rd, I can cite 1000's of others.
Does it have any enemies?
Would you be upset if some local corporation sold breakthrough military technology to that enemy?
Yes the US has Enemies,
No I would not be upset is some local corporation sold breakthrough military technology to that "enemy"...
I lived through the first cryptowars, I do not have the desire to give the government that kind of power
I see the resurgence of the new cryptowars on the horizon, government can not be trusted to choose what information should be public and what should be secret
The government shouldn't be forced to buy any type of military technology someone creates. But even if the government won't buy your tech, it still can be dangerous in the hands of other countries.
One could argue that if the government is preventing you from selling your tech abroad - there should be some sort of compensation for this. Others could argue that's just the cost of being in the business of weapons manufacturing.