Re:Clojure & Scala Similarities — Twins separated at birth?
by swannodette on Wednesday April 21, 2010 @10:52AM
(#1282309)
> "1. I think Clojure is much simpler"
Scala is now 170,000+ lines of code. Clojure on the other hand is about ~30,000 lines of Java and 4,000 lines of Clojure.
Scala brings a very sophisticated and robust type system. This has it's benefits but it also seems to inject a considerable amount of of complexity. I haven't experienced Scala's type system so I won't venture further than that. If somebody asked me where the complexity was in Clojure I would answer thus:
1. Understanding the roles of the various concurrency primitives
2. Making idiomatic Clojure fast w/o resorting to mutable Java
3. Macros (if you haven't written them before)
Besides these three areas, Clojure is mind-blowingly and beautifully simple. I've found it to be as "conceptually" small as C or JavaScript while adding an incredible amount of expressive power.
EDIT: I have no actual opinion about Scala. It looks like great technology.
Scala is now 170,000+ lines of code. Clojure on the other hand is about ~30,000 lines of Java and 4,000 lines of Clojure.
Scala brings a very sophisticated and robust type system. This has it's benefits but it also seems to inject a considerable amount of of complexity. I haven't experienced Scala's type system so I won't venture further than that. If somebody asked me where the complexity was in Clojure I would answer thus:
Besides these three areas, Clojure is mind-blowingly and beautifully simple. I've found it to be as "conceptually" small as C or JavaScript while adding an incredible amount of expressive power.EDIT: I have no actual opinion about Scala. It looks like great technology.