News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Richard Stallman: "I Wished I Had Killed Myself" by rbanffy on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @10:14PM (#1281205)
> programmers who went the commercial route (Gates et al)

It's a false dichotomy. There is no need to imprison (as Stallman would say) the user and disrespect his rights (at least to use, understand, improve) in order to be commercial. What "Gates et al" have done is to bind their users through the software they use to manage their lives and jobs, ensuring long-term prosperity through technological dependency.

The folks at Red Hat, Canonical and MindTouch (just to name a few I have in my head right now) are every bit as serious as Microsoft when it comes to be commercial and to be paid for their work.

The main difference being they show much more consideration towards their users and customers.

Re:Richard Stallman: "I Wished I Had Killed Myself" by chc on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @10:57PM (#1281274)
Red Hat, Canonical and MindTouch combined have not had as much impact on computing as Apple or Microsoft alone. I was going to qualify that, but no, I think it's pretty unequivocal.

Also, your selection of companies seems a bit deceptive. These companies' profit strategies are very narrowly focused on the one market where it's possible to make money with free software — and even that isn't really making money from the software. You have to be in a market where people will pay through the nose for support contracts, because the software itself isn't making much money.

The one real exception I can think of is Mozilla, which makes decent money off of Firefox. Otherwise, unfortunately, it does generally seem to be necessary to bind the users enough to make them pay you for the software. (That's not a sarcastic "unfortunately" — I do think it would be great if I could reasonably sell free software as profitably as non-free software, but I don't see any evidence that it's feasible.)

Re:Richard Stallman: "I Wished I Had Killed Myself" by rbanffy on Wednesday April 21, 2010 @07:01AM (#1281820)
> Red Hat, Canonical and MindTouch combined have not had as much impact on computing as Apple or Microsoft alone.

Wouldn't that be a question of time and business model? Apple is a hardware company and both were around when the PC (not the IBM one) was invented.

> isn't really making money from the software

It's very hard to directly make money from software sales if you grant your customers the right to share it. Software companies make money out of the scarcity of software ("You want Windows? Ask Microsoft"). Free software is naturally abundant. It's possible, but not easy, to make your users pay directly for it.

And Mozilla can't ask users to pay for it. Not only because it's infinitely abundant (anyone can give you one) but Microsoft's IE comes bundled in the OS most Firefox users run. Opera does that and look at their market share.

Re:Richard Stallman: "I Wished I Had Killed Myself" by chc on Wednesday April 21, 2010 @11:30AM (#1282404)
And that is why it is generally necessary to "imprison" (as Stallman would say) the user. Otherwise you're making a product that won't make money. There are a few markets where you might find a connected business to recoup the money you spent on software, but it's not a general business model for development.

That's what I was getting at: It's hard to be rewarded for free software, so there really is a dichotomy between free and commercial software. It's not just Jobs and friends being dicks and restricting customers.

Re:Richard Stallman: "I Wished I Had Killed Myself" by rbanffy on Wednesday April 21, 2010 @03:54PM (#1283129)
> you're making a product that won't make money

No. You are only making software that doesn't usually get sold. Most of it isn't, but you can custom-develop - building upon piles of other free software - and then license it under a free license to your client who chooses whether to share it (always under a free license) or not. Free software can be sold. I know this because I did it a lot.

> It's hard to be rewarded for free software

OTOH, it's much cheaper and easier to develop it. With closed software, you have to invent your own wheels. With free and open-source software, you are free to use the ramjet engines other people have developed.

Re:Richard Stallman: "I Wished I Had Killed Myself" by chc on Wednesday April 21, 2010 @05:35PM (#1283281)
Again, you're outlining a highly specialized business plan for custom development — not a general principle for making money with FOSS. If I freely license my next game, I'll lose my shirt. If I create an awesome, game-changing productivity suite and GPL it, I'll lose my shirt. If I do anything outside of some very tiny niches, I'll lose my shirt.

There are a few small areas where FOSS is as commercially viable as anything else, and you'll notice those are also generally the areas where it seems to be most mature. You can't generalize those tiny areas and say that making open-source software in general is a reliable income source.

Re:Richard Stallman: "I Wished I Had Killed Myself" by rbanffy on Wednesday April 21, 2010 @08:19PM (#1283644)
It's not possible to make a business out of selling goods that are infinitely abundant. Free software is one such thing.

Making open-source is not a direct income driver and, apart from very limited niches, will never be, but, nevertheless, it allows a business to have full control of its technology stack.

Company A builds a great game using a closed-source library built by company B and company C builds another great game using, say, an LGPL library. When the underlying platform changes, breaking both libraries, company C is not subject to whatever the strategy of company B is and, therefore, can be first to market with a new, compatible, version.

This is a hypothetical situation, of course, but illustrates one important thing about free software - most people don't really make it: they use it and, from time to time, and, if and when the need arises, add a little improvement here or a fix there. Its strength lies in the sheer number of people that give a little hand, scratching one another's itch.

Re:Richard Stallman: "I Wished I Had Killed Myself" by mishmash on Wednesday April 21, 2010 @02:26PM (#1282939)
>There are a few markets where you might find a connected business to recoup the money you spent on software, but it's not a general business model for development.

I wonder if more startups should remember this.

Re:Richard Stallman: "I Wished I Had Killed Myself" by apotheon on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @10:22PM (#1281216)
I agree.

I also believe that the "Stallman or nothing" suggested by so many of his fans is a false dichotomy. You don't need to be rabidly communistic about software to oppose the "imprisoning" influence of corporate software vendors, after all.

Re:Richard Stallman: "I Wished I Had Killed Myself" by rbanffy on Wednesday April 21, 2010 @07:06AM (#1281830)
No, you don't. And there are certainly some pressures not to do so, but, in the end, it's a rights issue - your right to control the tools that everyday grow more and more indispensable to participate in society and to protect your privacy.

But this attitude, of sacrificing "just a little" here and there for more convenience is not healthy either.

And then there is another false idea: Free Software is not about Communism. Communism is about the collective ownership of scarce resources. Free Software is the realization that software (as ideas and knowledge) are infinitely abundant.

Re:Richard Stallman: "I Wished I Had Killed Myself" by apotheon on Friday April 23, 2010 @12:50PM (#1288629)
The Stallman/FSF conception of "free software" is about communism, though. You don't need to give everything away for everything to be free. A copyfree license (BSD license, MIT/X11 license, OWL, et cetera) is just as much a "free software" license as a copyleft license, but doesn't make developers beholden to other developers and to the code itself. Rather, it makes the code beholden to developers and users, without making developers and users beholden to other developers and users.

The truth of the matter is that we're probably going to continue to see an increase in corporations using the GPL and (more to the point) other mutually incompatible copyleft licenses, because copyleft licenses can be extremely valuable for those who want to maintain control of the codebase while still getting the benefits of open source software, thus providing a way to sucker competitors into supporting your software "product" while still keeping an anticompetitive advantage by way of the MySQL AB business model and other ways to combine the GPL with proprietary licensing for market domination profit.

So, in summary . . . yes, it's true that "free software" in general isn't necessarily communistic or socialistic, but copyleft licensing in particular does bear a striking resemblance to various principles of communism and socialism. Just like communism and socialism, it also tends to get co-opted by market dominating monopolists and their ilk.