Re:American Children Are Drowning in Self-Esteem
by analog31 on Thursday October 27, 2016 @07:21PM
(#12811349)
My kids are in music lessons, the youth orchestra, etc., as I was at the same age. I also played in a rock band as a kid. I don't think that things have changed at all. Maybe the whole "self esteem" thing is an urban legend.
Everybody's enthusiastic at the performance, like you say.
At the next lesson, they review the recording. But then, they've been receiving that kind of critique at every lesson. You should hear the conductor let 'em have it at orchestra rehearsal. Because of this kind of dialog and close analysis, they also know exactly how well they're playing, immediately and intimately. Part of the goal is to teach kids how to engage in the critical dialog, and to be self-critiquing.
With the typical teen rock band, there is no adult involvement at all, other than fiscal.
Everybody's enthusiastic at the performance, like you say.
At the next lesson, they review the recording. But then, they've been receiving that kind of critique at every lesson. You should hear the conductor let 'em have it at orchestra rehearsal. Because of this kind of dialog and close analysis, they also know exactly how well they're playing, immediately and intimately. Part of the goal is to teach kids how to engage in the critical dialog, and to be self-critiquing.
With the typical teen rock band, there is no adult involvement at all, other than fiscal.