News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hitler “Downfall Meme” gets taken down by KirinDave on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @05:19PM (#1280636)
Is the article trying to suggest this is fair use under parody, at the end?

Seems like it wasn't really qualifying. Taking 5 minutes wholesale out of a movie and overlaying text is a tough sell for "parody", which typically involves shorter duration.

I hope someone challenges this ruling. It'd be interesting to see if we can expand what parody is.

Re:Hitler “Downfall Meme” gets taken down by hugh3 on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @05:40PM (#1280680)
I think what prevents this from being "parody" is that the thing being copied is not the thing being parodied. A "Downfall" parody video about Star Trek isn't a parody of Downfall, it's a parody of Star Trek, or maybe a parody of Star Trek fans.

Similarly, when Weird Al Yankovic ripped off Nirvana to make fun of Nirvana he didn't need to get permission to do so, but when he ripped off American Pie to make fun of Star Wars Episode 1 he did. (For the record, Weird Al nowadays always gets permission from the original artist anyway.)

Re:Hitler “Downfall Meme” gets taken down by tokenadult on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @07:54PM (#1280960)
"parody", which typically involves shorter duration.

Length of the excerpt has nothing whatsoever to do with whether or not a use is parody. Length of an excerpt compared to length of the whole work has something to do with whether or not a use is "fair use," and thus permitted without permission.

Similarly, parody is one purpose for adapting a copyrighted work, which is also a test of "fair use," with rather generous legal protection. The book Dave Barry's Book of Bad Songs

http://www.amazon.com/Dave-Barrys-Book-Bad-Songs/dp/08362144...

is an example of use that is fair use even though some of the quotations from some lyrics did NOT receive permission from the copyright holders--as is explicitly noted on the extensive credits page of Dave Barry's book.

Re:Hitler “Downfall Meme” gets taken down by smallblacksun on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @05:40PM (#1280679)
Artists like Weird Al use entire songs for parody, so I don't think a 5 minute clip would be too long.
Re:Hitler “Downfall Meme” gets taken down by InclinedPlane on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @05:44PM (#1280692)
Artists like Weird Al get permission from the original artists, they also don't use any original material, typically. For what it's worth.
Re:Hitler “Downfall Meme” gets taken down by ywgdana on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @06:49PM (#1280831)
Although they aren't legally required to. Al does it as a courtesy. He specifically gets permission from the artist now, because when he did Amish Paradise he'd received an okay from Coolio's label, but later learned Coolio himself was upset about the parody.
Re:Hitler “Downfall Meme” gets taken down by mikecane on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @07:07PM (#1280865)
See, the thing is, I don't know German, so how can it really be a theft of the movie if the original English subtitles aren't there for me to understand it? Doesn't comprehensibility figure into this at all?
Re:Hitler “Downfall Meme” gets taken down by KirinDave on Wednesday April 21, 2010 @01:54PM (#1282832)
It doesn't seem to.