News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An Economy of Liars by btilly on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @02:05PM (#1280125)
Ryan, I completely disagree. I am surprised that you would think that the society benefits more from the education than the individual. According to me, if I have higher education, I get a better job, better salary, more respect in social circle. Compared to this, what does society get if I am educated?

He never said more goes to society. He just said some of the benefit cannot be captured by the individual.

This is trivially true. Employers pay an individual somewhere between nothing and the value that individual contributes. If an educated individual contributes more than an uneducated one, then the educated individual is likely to get more salary than the uneducated one AND the employer has a larger gap between salary paid and value captured. (Incidentally there is typically a gap between the value provided by the employer and the revenue collected, which provides yet another layer of more broadly spread societal benefit that is not seen by the individual.)

That excess value is captured by private companies that may or may not even have existed at the time that the individual was being educated. That is value going to society that is not captured by the individual, and hence which can't be recouped through any kind of student loan program.

Re:An Economy of Liars by yummyfajitas on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @02:14PM (#1280157)
What you are describing are simply the gains from trade. They exist for any good or service which is voluntarily traded.

Therefore, if we favor subsidies for education, we should also favor subsidies for purchasing industrial machines, computers to automate labor, or any other investment.

Re:An Economy of Liars by btilly on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @03:57PM (#1280429)
Not any other investment, by a long shot. Because while there is a potential benefit to government assistance, there are also potential costs in terms of distorting markets, inefficient allocation, and creating oversupply. There is a trade-off, and finding the right one can be difficult.

That said, historically we've gotten surprisingly good returns from subsidies on research, transportation, and certain areas of telecom. (The early Internet is a shining example.) However a certain amount of caution needs to be maintained because once a precedent has been set then regulatory capture sets in and the long term result of those unintended consequences tends to be very bad.

Re:An Economy of Liars by yummyfajitas on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @04:50PM (#1280553)
Not any other investment, by a long shot. Because while there is a potential benefit to government assistance, there are also potential costs in terms of distorting markets, inefficient allocation, and creating oversupply.

The same possible harms also apply to education.

Re:An Economy of Liars by btilly on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @05:04PM (#1280591)
Absolutely that is possible. But when you look at historical data, and you compare the trajectories of countries with and without strong educational systems, publicly available education has proven to be a worthwhile investment.