News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Fiber Cutting Jobs and Halting Rollout by josh2600 on Wednesday October 26, 2016 @11:32AM (#12797277)
I wrote about this elsewhere and am pasting my thoughts here as I think they're relevant to this community:

1) Google Fiber is dead. Long Live Google ISP.

Google cannot afford to lay fiber in the ground because it's a long game and Google doesn't really want to play the long game (they just want to put pressure on competitors so they can move more bits along the wires, generating more searches and more streams with which to shove ads in your face). Fiber never was the most efficient way to do this, but there's something sexy about "Google Fiber" as opposed to "Google Point to Point Radio Towers". The reality is that wireless delivery of bits is way cheaper than fiber because you don't have to tear the ground up (over the last mile obviously since the arteries must be fiber links).

Clarification: "long" refers to 30-year payback periods for physical asset investment. There are a lot of things with higher returns on that timeline than fiber that google can invest in. I don't actually think it's profitable for anyone to build unsubsidized networks. This is why networks should be public and operators should be private, but that's a topic for another day!

2) Fiber is cheap, construction is expensive.

When I helped Comcast build out the fiber network in SF, what struck me was the relative cheapness of the assets we were putting in the ground compared to the cost of tearing up the street. The conduit and the glass inside the conduit cost almost nothing, but tearing up the street in SF is $300/sq ft. Crossing cable car tracks was like $50,000. Then there's the actual cost of construction: people. Getting contractors to arrive on time, finish on time, and avoid overtime is fraught with peril. It's actually really hard to move physical atoms around in a manner similar to programmatic systems, and so many models that have real world elements stumble against the harshness of actuality. I suspect Google's cost modeling for building a fiber network was optimistic.

3) Wireless is fast, but does it scale to city size?

It's not hard or particularly expensive to deliver gigabit over wireless. You basically need a tall building to rain down radio waves onto the masses. What I wonder about, given that we have no cities running on majority wireless point to points, is what happens when you hit scale? That is to say, point to points have a limited wireless footprint (because using beamforming we don't need to splay the signal everywhere, we just send it in one direction), but one can easily imagine a saturated wireless environment as generating a significant amount of noise. Wireless networks are easy when there's only a few objects on the network but get significantly harder as the physical area reaches device saturation. That is to say, WebPass might be super easy to operate when only a handful of buildings are on WebPass, but it might be much harder if a whole section of the city is online.

4) Google bought WebPass a while back.

The writing has been on the wall for a while that the fiber game was killing uncle Google. I can only hope that they don't bow out completely. I think that wireless makes Google significantly less of an existential threat to their carrier partners as well.

Overall, I remain cautiously optimistic about Google's future as an ISP.

On a final note: Google Fi is not an answer to Google fiber disappearing. The two are tangential, disjointed offerings that cannot, for a bunch of reasons, compete with one another (most notably the wireless data caps).

Re:Google Fiber Cutting Jobs and Halting Rollout by j3097736 on Wednesday October 26, 2016 @05:45PM (#12800939)
>What I wonder about, given that we have no cities running on majority wireless point to points, is what happens when you hit scale?

As long as there is line of sight, the tower has fiber, the hardware upgraded as the network grows and beamforming technology continues to improve it shouldn't be an issue.

Re:Google Fiber Cutting Jobs and Halting Rollout by josh2600 on Thursday October 27, 2016 @11:56AM (#12806177)
I know of no city in the world that operates a primary network of point to points. I think it's a fascinating engineering problem with a bunch of unknown problems that will arise in the process of attempting to deliver the solution.

Things break in exciting ways at scale :).

Re:Google Fiber Cutting Jobs and Halting Rollout by csours on Wednesday October 26, 2016 @11:40AM (#12797360)
Do you have to literally dig up the street? If so, why?
Re:Google Fiber Cutting Jobs and Halting Rollout by josh2600 on Wednesday October 26, 2016 @12:17PM (#12797739)
To put the fiber in the ground.

There are pieces of conduit that we run fiber through into your building. Inside your building there's a fiber termination point that hands off to ethernet. On the other end is a repeater/node that boosts the signal from the other termination point back in the DC.

Re:Google Fiber Cutting Jobs and Halting Rollout by garrettgrimsley on Wednesday October 26, 2016 @05:17PM (#12800651)
I'm not expert on this, but I think that the use of a horizontal drill is more common.

Check out this horizontal drill: http://www.ballantineinc.com/sites/default/files/img/Copy%20...

See this diagram for how they're used: http://www.ajvac.ca/images/directional%20drill%20diag2.jpg

Re:Google Fiber Cutting Jobs and Halting Rollout by RyJones on Wednesday October 26, 2016 @06:27PM (#12801267)
For a city like San Francisco, only a fraction of what is in the ground is mapped. The only reasonable option is many places is to dig up the ground and look at what you're working with.

Even in the area I live in, ripping up the streets is how it's done. I've only seen horizontal boring machines deployed a few times around here. Maybe they're used a lot and I don't notice them because I don't have to drive around them, but I do keep a eye open for them in the wild. I considered renting or buying one for a project and was impressed how cheap they are, but the benefit of burying things versus the price - no contest.

What I learned, though, is there are eBay-like markets for TBMs and it seems most people buy one with so many hours on it, use it for a project, and sell it +so many hours. I didn't find the thriving rental market I expected.

Re:Google Fiber Cutting Jobs and Halting Rollout by josh2600 on Thursday October 27, 2016 @12:18AM (#12802879)
I can confirm that horizontal boring machines have never been used in any telco digging opportunity I've been a part of :/. I wish it were the case but it is all tear-up-the-streets territory.
Re:Google Fiber Cutting Jobs and Halting Rollout by StillBored on Thursday October 27, 2016 @12:22AM (#12802890)
No, and AFAIK, in Austin all the early roll outs were in older neighborhoods with physical poles. I'm not sure if google was lashing their cables to existing lines, but I saw TWC doing that a lot when they were splitting nodes here. It was amazingly fast they would show up with a truck and lash a half mile of cable in a couple hours.

Of course one of the early slowdowns was AT&T throwing a fit about google sharing poles owned by AT&T.

Re:Google Fiber Cutting Jobs and Halting Rollout by josh2600 on Thursday October 27, 2016 @08:31AM (#12804512)
1) pole rights matter. In San Francisco, att also owns the poles and does everything they can to prevent other people from using them. I would tell installs that it would be 30 days from the day we got permitted until the circuit was installed, but that despite there being a 30-day limit on replies for pole permits, many times att would wait 180 days before issuing access permits. It was honestly a joke around the office.

2) many cities do not have above-ground power and fewer still have above-ground telco without power. I have not researched this extensively so I am not sure if google picked places with poles specifically, but that would be a smart move. That being said, imagining att would let them use the poles was not really reasonable.

Re:Google Fiber Cutting Jobs and Halting Rollout by mrevolution on Wednesday October 26, 2016 @11:52AM (#12797486)
May the solution be Project Loon?
Re:Google Fiber Cutting Jobs and Halting Rollout by josh2600 on Wednesday October 26, 2016 @12:18PM (#12797742)
That depends on how you feel about airspace rights.