News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Recent trends in grade inflation at American universities by hga on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @11:52AM (#1279727)
To take a topical example, I'm sure MIT's EECS department looks like a candidate for a grade inflation accusation after the dot.com crash.

What really happened is that when enrollment also crashed, the students still taking the major were serious about it per se, not just as a good and high paying career (hah!).

So nowadays almost all the students are making As and Bs, with the notable exceptions being those going through some sort of personal crisis unrelated to academics.

And thinking about it, to the extent the 1/5 of MIT's students who are no longer taking EECS are instead in majors that they are a better match for, I'd expect their grades to increase as well.

Or look at the cancellation of the Superconducting Supercollider. Some departments had lines of students switching their majors out of physics; to the extent those students found their new majors easier (physics is hard) I would expect a bit of "grade inflation" as well.

A final note on MIT: this is not the first time this site has been forwarded to HN, and I'll note again that its grade inflation ended in 1970. It was pretty much a phenomena of the turbulent cultural '60s (which didn't quite start in 1960), which is not surprising for a whole bunch of reasons, e.g. I'm pretty sure MIT decided to make itself a bit less difficult to succeed in (e.g. when I attended in 1979-80, the entire freshman year was pass/fail, now it's only the first term, and I'm sure before the '60s they didn't do this).

Oh, that rule of thumb predicts 3.00, while MIT including the freshmen is 3.17. Given the tremendous self-selection in the applicants, that's interesting.

There are no comments on this comment yet.