Re:Computing glitch may have doomed Mars lander
by scrollaway on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @08:09AM
(#12787175)
> No software that I know of is engineered to the same level of precision as hardware.
Are you counting NASA-produced software? I'm not familiar with ESA's software pipeline but I imagine it's similar.
Re:Computing glitch may have doomed Mars lander
by tremon on Wednesday October 26, 2016 @05:48AM
(#12795149)
Sadly, I'm not. I truly wish I could say that NASA-produced software is within the range of "software that I know of", but it's not.
Re:Computing glitch may have doomed Mars lander
by jack1243star on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @08:11AM
(#12787187)
Computing Needs Time [1], which focuses on the handling of time, is a nice read on this topic from the software point of view.
[1] http://digitalassets.lib.berkeley.edu/techreports/ucb/text/E...
That's hard to say in general. With current practices, I'd say software is harder to get right, but that is mainly due to a failure to spec correctly. Hardware is engineered with very tight controls: dimensions, shapes, and properties are all produced according to a specification that doesn't just specify its nominal values, but also the acceptable tolerance for any deviations.
No software that I know of is engineered to the same level of precision as hardware. The lack of specification-guided tooling (and validation for 3rd-party components) is what puts software development not even in the same league as hardware development.