Re:Apple Introduces What It Calls an Easier to Use Portable ...
by icebraining on Monday October 24, 2016 @06:39PM
(#12783539)
Compared to any device that had a USB port and hence actually worked with our PCs.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Apple Introduces What It Calls an Easier to Use Portable ...
by honkhonkpants on Monday October 24, 2016 @07:11PM
(#12783730)
See, that's just the thing right there. Jobs wanted to market a great product and was in no way concerned that some people might not be able to use it, because expanding the product to those users would compromise the greatness of the product. USB ports with comparable speeds to FireWire had only just been released on PCs when the iPod came to market, and charging a battery over USB was at that time just an abuse of the specification, whereas FireWire was designed from the beginning to provide 15W nominally and up to 45W tolerated. USB did not reach FireWire levels of battery charging ability until 2012!
Re:Apple Introduces What It Calls an Easier to Use Portable ...
by MagnumOpus on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @04:12AM
(#12786099)
Yes, Jobs was short-sighted and made a bad business decision by not supporting 95%+ of his potential customer base.
He subsequently did a 180 on this decision - Gen 3 introduced USB syncing, Gen 4 introduced USB charging, Gen 5 dropped Firewire syncing - and hey presto, the iPod started selling more than 5 million units a year, started being profitable and swallowed the entire competition.
Re:Apple Introduces What It Calls an Easier to Use Portable ...
by honkhonkpants on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @11:45AM
(#12788890)
You're applying your own success criteria to someone else's project.
Re:Apple Introduces What It Calls an Easier to Use Portable ...
by FabHK on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @01:11AM
(#12785471)
Exactly. Firewire = charging + super speed. iTunes was Mac only at the time, for (relatively) easy management and syncing of your music.
Re:Apple Introduces What It Calls an Easier to Use Portable ...
by xenadu02 on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @12:44AM
(#12785352)
> Compared to any device that had a USB port and hence actually worked with our PCs
USB 2 wasn't even ratified until the end of 2001 after the original iPod's introduction. Do you know how long it would have taken to sync 1000 songs over USB 1.0? 1000 * 5MB/song (avg) / 1.25MB/sec = 4000 seconds or over an hour.
Firewire was able to stream data at disk write speed which would have been anywhere from 5-20MB/sec.
Re:Apple Introduces What It Calls an Easier to Use Portable ...
by icebraining on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @04:28AM
(#12786182)
Who cared? It's not like I listened to a thousand songs every day and had to write a thousand more every night. It took an hour the first time to fill it up, then I'd only replace an album or two at a time.