His biggest returns for the first 3/4 of his adult life involved him going against the market when equities were out of favor and scooping up extremely large positions in the likes of The Washington Post, GEICO, American Express, Wells Fargo and Coca Cola.
His extraordinary history of stock picking is what enabled him to begin buying entire substantial businesses in the first place. The stock picking is what accumulated the capital necessary to buy Blue Chip Stamps and See's Candies. The Buffett partnerships for example were not built around buying up entire businesses and operating them for decades to reinvest the cash flow, and yet his returns were dramatic - regularly stomping the Dow - during those years precisely because he was such a great stock picker.
The advantage he had in the GS preferred stock offering in 2008 was his ability to provide liquidity and his name - if GS told people that Warren was investing in them then it was a real vote of confidence.