With compressed files you usually need it to be perfect to recovery any data, but you can use fixtar [0] to recover some data from a corrupted tar archive.
I used BluRay as the media cost is about the same as DVDs per GB here (at least 25GB discs). Also there are HTL discs available, which supposidely have a greater longevity than DVDs.
[0] -http://riaschissl.bestsolution.at/2015/03/repair-corrupt-tar...
What's the oldest disc you've tested?
What do you think about PAR3?
I just tried a DVD from 2013 (Verbatim DVD-R, 16x, 4.7 GB) and it read fine, without any errors, and dvdisaster found that the checksums on it matched.
I usually try to use at least 20% redundancy, but will settle for less if the data's not very important. If the data's really important I'll max out the amount of redundancy (up to dvdisaster's limit, which I don't remember off-hand). Sometimes I'll even burn an extra DVD with the same data, both with dvdisaster error correction on them.
As for par3, I only heard about it for the first time today in this thread. So I have no opinions on it except to say that if it's an improvement over par2, I'm all for it. Backwards compatibility with par2 also would be nice.
When I burn data (including xz archives) on to DVD for archival storage, I use dvdisaster[2] for the same purpose.
I've tested both by damaging archives and scratching DVDs, and these tools work great for recovery. The amount of redundancy (with a tradeoff for space) is also tuneable for both.
[1] - https://github.com/BlackIkeEagle/par2cmdline
[2] - http://dvdisaster.net/