Re:Xz format inadequate for long-term archiving
by saurik on Saturday October 22, 2016 @12:21PM
(#12769277)
> xz wasn't chosen for its archival integrity AFAIK, it was chosen for its size.
No: that's why the LZMA compression algorithm is being used. The switch from the original LZMA container format to the "improved" xz container format had nothing to do with size, as the old container generated slightly smaller files in addition to not having this combination of negative properties.
Re:Xz format inadequate for long-term archiving
by amaranth on Saturday October 22, 2016 @04:30PM
(#12770438)
I remember the hype around LZMA2 and xz being that, because it uses blocks, you can do the compression and decompression on multiple threads. LZMA was generally considered too slow to use for regular usage (only for archival, basically) and multicore was the new way to scale so this was perfect.
xz wasn't chosen for its archival integrity AFAIK, it was chosen for its size. Package distribution ought to spend as much resource as practical to reduce bytes over the wire. Size is why bzip2 "won" over gz despite being many times slower and requiring much more RAM. lrzip would be my first choice for maximum compression, but its downstream resource requirements are far too high vs any of the others, so from my experience xz would be the answer anyway.