News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Today's Brutal DDoS Attack Is the Beginning of a Bleak Fu... by Animats on Friday October 21, 2016 @03:13PM (#12763633)
Dyn, Inc. is toast. They created a central point of failure for the Internet. Major sites will stop using their services within hours.

Things need to get more distributed. Don't load Jquery from some central site. Don't load fonts from Google. Make sure your site will work if all the trackers and ad sites are not responding. Use multiple independent DNS providers.

It's also time for serious litigation. Find some vulnerable IoT device being used for the attack, and sue the retailer, distributor, and manufacturer for negligence. Junk IoT manufacturers need to feel fear.

Re:Today's Brutal DDoS Attack Is the Beginning of a Bleak Fu... by stcredzero on Friday October 21, 2016 @03:23PM (#12763742)
Junk IoT manufacturers need to feel fear.

We've reached the point where any clueless business type who pooh-poohs and wishes away security concerns needs to get the idiot bit flipped on them. Today's networked computing environment has reached the point, where this stuff is toxic. It might have been okay for a few isolated frontier weirdos to play with mercury to extract gold, but then when that became a full blown industry, it resulted in toxic consequences we are still dealing with over 150 years later. Maker hipsters playing with a few hardware hacks did little harm. Now that IoT is becoming household, the situation has changed in an analogous way.

Re:Today's Brutal DDoS Attack Is the Beginning of a Bleak Fu... by Florin_Andrei on Friday October 21, 2016 @04:02PM (#12764128)
Selling insecure devices (be that IoT, wifi routers, etc) is almost like aiding and abetting, in the context of DoS attacks.
Re:Today's Brutal DDoS Attack Is the Beginning of a Bleak Fu... by Kunix on Friday October 21, 2016 @04:07PM (#12764170)
If they had to recall all vulnerable devices I am sure they would take security a lot more seriously.
Re:Today's Brutal DDoS Attack Is the Beginning of a Bleak Fu... by boredprogrammer on Friday October 21, 2016 @04:30PM (#12764421)
capitalism just isn't ready for prime time
Re:Today's Brutal DDoS Attack Is the Beginning of a Bleak Fu... by stcredzero on Friday October 21, 2016 @06:09PM (#12765340)
It's the worst way to organize an economy, after every single other way we've thought of so far.
Re:Today's Brutal DDoS Attack Is the Beginning of a Bleak Fu... by rbinv on Friday October 21, 2016 @03:16PM (#12763665)
Please. Dyn has performed pretty well in the past, and any other provider (be it UltraDNS, CloudFlare or anybody else) would be a single point of failure as well.

As you said, the only protection (somewhat) is to have redundant/multiple DNS providers. Doesn't mean Dyn can't be one of many.

Re:Today's Brutal DDoS Attack Is the Beginning of a Bleak Fu... by Bartweiss on Friday October 21, 2016 @04:15PM (#12764259)
Dyn is still one of the biggest and hardest to hit providers, so I'd be surprised if they're broadly abandoned. Redundant providers are pretty much the only fix available to users, but it's still sensible to be redundant via the the best providers out there, and that still means Dyn.
Re:Today's Brutal DDoS Attack Is the Beginning of a Bleak Fu... by Animats on Friday October 21, 2016 @03:23PM (#12763745)
They had one job. To stay up no matter what. That's the only justification for using Dyn. They failed.
Re:Today's Brutal DDoS Attack Is the Beginning of a Bleak Fu... by rbinv on Friday October 21, 2016 @03:26PM (#12763772)
Yes, they did. But, depending on the details of the attack, I am not sure if any other provider could have withstood the attack without problems. In other words, I doubt there's a single provider/alternative.
Re:Today's Brutal DDoS Attack Is the Beginning of a Bleak Fu... by detaro on Friday October 21, 2016 @05:06PM (#12764820)
Unless you have a good argument why they are less likely to stay up than the alternatives, I don't see how this would lead to their end. Unless you take it as an argument to abolish ALL DNS servers and start mailing host-files around...

People have been painfully reminded why using multiple providers is best practice, will re-evaluate if that's worth the expense and if yes add other servers. Dyn will easily survive unless some massive blunder is exposed in the aftermath.

Re:Today's Brutal DDoS Attack Is the Beginning of a Bleak Fu... by meira on Friday October 21, 2016 @05:42PM (#12765130)
The alternative, not being one of the bigs, has a lot less chance to be hit. I would leave dyndns the same way I'm leaving cloudflare.
Re:Today's Brutal DDoS Attack Is the Beginning of a Bleak Fu... by a3n on Friday October 21, 2016 @03:57PM (#12764073)
No matter what is pretty tough. And it's not like they're an insurance company that can re-insure their risks.

The people who depend on DNS have one DNS-related job: to mitigate risk relative to their potential losses and existence.

Re:Today's Brutal DDoS Attack Is the Beginning of a Bleak Fu... by Bartweiss on Friday October 21, 2016 @04:17PM (#12764279)
Would anyone else have stayed up, though? This isn't just going to be a fear response, the risk assessment will be to ask "what could have prevented this?"

Lots of people will quit using Dyn as a sole DNS, but I don't see any reason they'll quit being involved in people's multiple DNS solutions.

Re:Today's Brutal DDoS Attack Is the Beginning of a Bleak Fu... by cheald on Friday October 21, 2016 @04:26PM (#12764380)
Dyn is toast as a single DNS provider. The big boys are just going to move to using two or three providers' nameservers rather than just one.

Dyn will almost certainly remain as one of those two or three.

Re:Today's Brutal DDoS Attack Is the Beginning of a Bleak Fu... by eternalban on Friday October 21, 2016 @03:45PM (#12763958)
> load fonts from Google.

Not sure, but isn't this yet another beacon?

Re:Today's Brutal DDoS Attack Is the Beginning of a Bleak Fu... by jazoom on Friday October 21, 2016 @10:54PM (#12766850)
It's hardly dire if the custom fonts don't load for a few hours.
Re:Today's Brutal DDoS Attack Is the Beginning of a Bleak Fu... by smn1234 on Friday October 21, 2016 @03:16PM (#12763666)
can you imagine the cost of doing and having everything nX times ??
Re:Today's Brutal DDoS Attack Is the Beginning of a Bleak Fu... by apathy on Friday October 21, 2016 @10:56PM (#12766858)
Presumably about n-fold higher (marginally) than without redundancy. Not counting the cost of this sort of outage, which could swing the equation strongly in favor of nX