Re:Dan Meyer dissects the flaws of math textbooks (video)
by olliesaunders on Sunday April 18, 2010 @05:59PM
(#1275586)
You can give yours students an incredibly useful skill that has inordinate practical application, exciting their minds with possibilities, intrigue, and a sense of empowerment. Or you can engage them in rote mechanics, fail to impart the usefulness of mathematics, and send them all to sleep.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Dan Meyer dissects the flaws of math textbooks (video)
by yequalsx on Sunday April 18, 2010 @06:10PM
(#1275607)
Great generalization and oversimplification. How about this oversimplification?
Or you can teach a generation of students that if isn't 'practical' then it shouldn't be done and certainly isn't worth any effort or struggle.
Hopefully then, we can eliminate poetry, music, art, literature, and p.e. We have practical problems to solve!
Re:Dan Meyer dissects the flaws of math textbooks (video)
by olliesaunders on Sunday April 18, 2010 @10:26PM
(#1275917)
I consider engaging and consuming forms of art akin to play. At first sight to spend lots of time playing might be seen as a waste of time but the fact that a child prevented from playing would fail to develop properly says something about its purpose. Basically I don't agree that those subjects are purposeless.
Re:Dan Meyer dissects the flaws of math textbooks (video)
by yequalsx on Sunday April 18, 2010 @10:43PM
(#1275948)
That's great that you consider this. Many do not consider poetry, music, art classes worthwhile because they consider those classes impractical.
I don't agree that learning how to abstractly apply rules and manipulate objects is useless. It's particularly important in programming, for instance.
Re:Dan Meyer dissects the flaws of math textbooks (video)
by nitrogen on Monday April 19, 2010 @01:14AM
(#1276130)
I think the other poster was suggesting that students will perceive abstract symbolic manipulation as useless unless they're taught why it isn't useless, probably via application problems. Considering that the majority of students will never have a genuine interest in math for its own sake, I think that textbooks and curricula designed for public education should include high doses of application problems, with enough theoretical problems to interest the true mathematicians and verify the students' understanding of the abstract concepts.