News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Innovation in rail travel: The train that never stops at ... by asimjalis on Sunday April 18, 2010 @10:36AM (#1274879)
Implementing the idea and making it work safely would be quite innovative. I can see a lot of things going wrong.

* What if the door on the pick-up car gets blocked? Sometimes straggling passengers hold the door open for their friends. It would need to get out of the way to prevent a collision with the drop-off car.

* What if there is a malfunction in the pick-up car so that it is not able to accelerate fast enough to catch up with the train?

* From an engineering point of view this seems fragile -- there are a lot of parts that need to perfectly synchronize with each other. A single error will quickly cascade through the system and result in serious loss of life.

Re:Innovation in rail travel: The train that never stops at ... by hxa7241 on Sunday April 18, 2010 @04:11PM (#1275404)
Yes, and weighing the whole thing against alternatives makes it questionable.

First, it might save lots of energy, but it is also a lot more complicated than just having brakes, which it is going to have anyway.

And how much energy would it really save? It still has to accelerate that detachable portion which could be a substantial fraction of the whole, and furthermore the train would probably need to be substantially heavier to support the extra mechanism, which would be a loss . . .

Still, it is a creative leap, which makes one think about how to be similarly inventive. You have to get some wild ideas before figuring out the details.

Re:Innovation in rail travel: The train that never stops at ... by lftl on Sunday April 18, 2010 @10:18PM (#1275904)
I'm less worried about energy, and more about time. Not having to stop at every stop along a route would cut a lot of commute time, and make adding more stops more feasible.
Re:Innovation in rail travel: The train that never stops at ... by KiwiNige on Sunday April 18, 2010 @11:38PM (#1276002)
>> but it is also a lot more complicated than just having brakes

At least one train maker still struggles getting this bit right. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siemens_%28train%29#Braking_iss...

I'd be very worried about safety with something this complex unless it could be proven to always fail in a safe way.

Re:Innovation in rail travel: The train that never stops at ... by RiderOfGiraffes on Sunday April 18, 2010 @05:10PM (#1275511)
It saves a lot of energy. Accelerating one part can be done by taking energy from the incoming sub/super carriage. Accelerating and decellerating the smaller carriages is much more efficient than the whole train.
Re:Innovation in rail travel: The train that never stops at ... by krschultz on Sunday April 18, 2010 @06:02PM (#1275589)
Are you sure? How much extra air drag will there be having a hump that basically doubles the frontal area and adds a load of form drag?