LDAP is a protocol. NoSQL is a shitload of software that works extremely different and has no protocol or common data scheme. LDAP is probably most used for organizing a companies data (employees) and works quite well for that. It's proven, it has major software products that are stable and used in worldwide deployments.
Just exchanging LDAP with NoSQL makes no sense and is a move only driven by "LDAP sounds soo old. Let's use that NoSQL everyone is talking about!". And maybe slap XML, Web2.0 and HTML5 on top of it. Just, you know.. it's state of the art!
I've yet to see a comment on this page that relates to the problems of the protocol. Mostly vague points without objective data.
Basing all those criticism on the fact that this protocol has been around or a while and thus has more than one RFC is just stupid.
I don't have the answers, I just didn't really like my experience with LDAP, and was idly wondering whether it'd be possible to build something better these days.
Do you have specific things in mind?
That said, there are plenty of systems that I have encountered in my years that are much friendlier to a new user. Specifically, I recall awful command line queries, kind of wonky tools in general, and, generally, a fiddly feeling to the whole thing. I did get things working, but I was never really happy with the whole setup. We ended up calling in a consultant to check over my work and see if there were ways to improve it, and aside from a few things, there really weren't.