Re:Bedrock – Rock-solid distributed data
by spotman on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @11:18AM
(#12744534)
My point is that if they are advertising rock solid distributed data, I don't think they have achieved that without putting it through some more paces.
I agree, actual numbers are great.
We also agree, jespen is great.
But I am saying, another path, to a similar level of confidence jespen provides, is some real critical stress testing.
Sure, it will be out of the scope of what most people need, but it will give them the confidence to say "rock solid distributed data".
Re:Bedrock – Rock-solid distributed data
by justinclift on Thursday October 20, 2016 @11:44AM
(#12753315)
Some of these FIXME's in Bedrock's er... Paxos implementation look like they could be important:
https://github.com/Expensify/Bedrock/blob/ecda922dc279e06fda...
And seeing actual numbers are important, too. People often act like in terms of write volume you're either shared hosting fodder, or you're Facebook, but there's a lot of room in between, and a lot of HA workloads are very read-dominated. It's very hard to find information about the businesses fall in the middle of that spectrum because usually no technology company talks about its traffic unless it's bragging about it (and then will release only vague information that could be spun in lots of different ways--for instance, not to call you out, I have no clue what "HA" means in your context, whether you need distributed transactions, whether the writes are cleanly partitionable, what isolation level you need, what your latency requirements are, or what the read:write ratio looks like). So I'd rather encourage people to release their numbers than poo-poo them because they aren't as big as whatever the biggest system you've worked on is.