Re:Why American Elections are Flawed, and How to Fix Them
by ClayShentrup on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @12:04PM
(#12745016)
The correct social welfare function is cardinal/utilitarian. Math that proves this.
http://scorevoting.net/UtilFoundns.html
So the right answer is presumably #3, although you didn't specify exact utilities so I don't know for sure.
Re:Why American Elections are Flawed, and How to Fix Them
by johnsonav on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @10:31AM
(#12744092)
Under approval voting, wouldn't the people who love candidate 1 realize that they should vote strategically, and not approve of candidate 3 on their ballots, causing candidate 1 to win this election?
Re:Why American Elections are Flawed, and How to Fix Them
by ClayShentrup on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @12:05PM
(#12745022)
One question to ask yourself to figure out which system you like better is what the outcome should be of this election:
Candidate 1 is loved by 55% of the population and despised by 45%. Candidate 2 is loved by 45% of the population and despised by 55%. Candidate 3 is tolerated by 85%.
Approval Voting would choose Candidate 3. IRV would choose Candidate 1. Who "should" be elected?