News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Renter’s Manifesto by chime on Sunday April 18, 2010 @12:22AM (#1274327)
Every now and then I see articles like these. It always seems to me that the author is simply trying to justify the fact that they rent. Renting vs. buying is a very personal decision and has a lot more to do with lifestyle and personal choices than financial soundness. I bought my house in 2005 at almost the top of housing market in Florida. I paid $145k for my house and told everyone about how smart of a financial decision I was making. I've spent $15k in home improvements and my house is now worth $125k. Oops. However, my mortgage is still very low and I can easily afford it regardless of the current worth.

Now the question is, if I could see the future back in 2005, would I still buy this house? If all I could see was the housing crash of 2008-2009, then of course not. But if I could see the great times I've had in this house which includes absolute peace and quiet, friendly neighbors who don't change every other month, and the feeling of a little place by the beach to call my own, I would indeed buy this house. Buying a house has a lot more to do with making it a home than just a shelter for cheap.

Nobody knows the future. I could have rented this exact house and instead of benefiting in the long run, I could have ended up losing more money if rent prices skyrocketed. All I know is that for people who can afford to buy and afford to rent, money has very little to do with buying vs. renting.

Re:The Renter’s Manifesto by Retric on Sunday April 18, 2010 @12:54AM (#1274371)
Renting vs. buying is a very personal decision and has a lot more to do with lifestyle and personal choices than financial soundness. Says someone that bought a home.

I want to walk to work and there are no homes for sale in my area. So even if I make 500k / year home ownership would still bring significant negative for my lifestyle. When you consider commuting costs, home ownership is both risky and far more expensive for most young people.

Re:The Renter’s Manifesto by hugh3 on Sunday April 18, 2010 @01:07AM (#1274388)
Sounds like a peculiar area if it doesn't have any homes for sale. Still, there must be just as many areas which don't have any homes for rent, right?
Re:The Renter’s Manifesto by Retric on Sunday April 18, 2010 @08:57AM (#1274758)
I said walking to work that's not exactly a huge area. Now 2 miles from me there are homes for sale, but driving that distance and parking in a parking garage is far more time consuming than walking. Taking a bike could also be an option.
Re:The Renter’s Manifesto by hugh3 on Sunday April 18, 2010 @11:17AM (#1274932)
Really? I walk three miles to work most days. (No, it's not uphill both ways).
Re:The Renter’s Manifesto by Retric on Sunday April 18, 2010 @10:25PM (#1275915)
It's a lifestyle thing, I can walk home for lunch watch something on Hulu / DVR and then go back to work all within my lunch hour. It might not seem like it but there really is a difference between a 3 minute commute and a 15 minute one.

PS: Walking 2+ miles in my area is slower than than driving that far and all I really care about is the time.

Re:The Renter’s Manifesto by vl on Sunday April 18, 2010 @01:04AM (#1274385)
Well, you are talking about $145k, in Bay Area or in Seattle, for example, you can't buy any house at all for this price. Would you still buy this house if it would cost you 600k?
Re:The Renter’s Manifesto by hugh3 on Sunday April 18, 2010 @01:16AM (#1274395)
Exactly. It seems to me that the only people who really need to worry about the economics of renting vs buying are those for whom houses are very expensive; either because they live in an expensive area or because they have low incomes. If you can buy all the house you need for $150K and you're earning at least, say, $50K then by all means go ahead and buy a house for the lifestyle reasons. But if the house you need costs ten times your annual salary then you need to think a lot more carefully.
Re:The Renter’s Manifesto by chime on Sunday April 18, 2010 @09:16AM (#1274781)
Like I said:

> All I know is that for people who can afford to buy and afford to rent, money has very little to do with buying vs. renting.

If I could afford to buy a $600k house and afford to rent a similar house in the same location, whether I buy or not would depend on my personal choice (which is to buy, not rent). If I can't afford to buy, then why even get into a debate. Of course I will rent.

Re:The Renter’s Manifesto by tpz on Sunday April 18, 2010 @01:05AM (#1274387)
Agreed.

re: "It always seems to me that the author is simply trying to justify the fact that they rent." - this always seems to be the case. The few renters who seem to do well financially would also do well financially as homeowners but for some reason have convinced themselves that the numbers work out better for renting. Maybe it does for those people, maybe it doesn't. I'll come back to that point in the next paragraph. In the meantime, however, the vast majority of renters one might speak to are just pissing away money, are no further in terms of savings than those with mortgages, and have none of the equity built up that those with mortgages have, even those who are pretty new to their mortgages.

Now, back to whether or not those "smart" renters are any better off. First off, I'll readily admit that my single data point is just that, but it bears consideration nonetheless. I bought property in 2005. In a neighbourhood with some growth potential, in an overall market with generally upward movement. Nothing bullish, just generally upward movement. In fact, that movement had been slowing a bit at that point, and continued to slow somewhat more afterwards. We all know what happened next. I sold early this year. I wonder how many smart renters could have done this _well_, even given the shitty few years I happened to own before selling: I paid $500 more per month than what I would have paid to rent the same space (in other words, put me up against a smart renter with $500 to invest each month), for a total of $30,000 "invested" progressively over those five years. I sold for a net profit of $125,000 after all fees, commissions, etc. In a hesitant market still recovering from the nasty troubles we all know too well.

Find me a renter with that kind of ROI on their investments over the last 5 years and I'll congratulate them over a nice lunch which I'll be happy to buy for them.

(crickets)

Yeah, I thought so.

Re:The Renter’s Manifesto by zacharypinter on Sunday April 18, 2010 @10:19AM (#1274862)
"Find me a renter with that kind of ROI on their investments over the last 5 years" is asking the wrong question.

While it's true that there are wins to be made in real estate (and I congratulate you on your successful outcome), there are also losses. Not only did you pay $500 more a month, you took a risk (the degree of which depends on your circumstances) that the home would rise in value. Had it not done so, you'd be stuck paying $500 more a month in addition to other potentially large losses.

Renting is (generally) lower cost, lower risk, lower potential ROI. Buying is (generally) higher cost, higher risk, higher potential ROI.

Re:The Renter’s Manifesto by rue on Sunday April 18, 2010 @07:46AM (#1274705)
> I sold for a net profit of $125,000 after all fees, commissions, etc.

Where does that "value" come from? The entire real estate market is built on the premise of property valuation continuously raising - causing and eventually surpassing inflation. This is without even accounting for the actual exploitation/gaming of the system.

Everyone has already forgotten, or chosen not to think about it in favour of short-term gain.

Re:The Renter’s Manifesto by earl on Sunday April 18, 2010 @01:19AM (#1274402)
The fact that you got lucky and timed the market doesn't mean other people should attempt to do the same, or that they will have any success doing so.
Re:The Renter’s Manifesto by tpz on Sunday April 18, 2010 @01:23AM (#1274408)
If I were lucky or if I had made any effort whatsoever to time the market, you might be right. On the other hand, I know of lots of data points like mine, even with the crapfest of the last couple of years. (Sensationalist news articles and statistics about idiots lending too much money to other idiots really shouldn't hold much water to the HN audience, if you think about it.) Regardless, find me that renter and I'll buy them a nice lunch. If I could have made $125,000 during those years then by their own arguments all of these "smart" renters should have been able to do the same through some alternate portfolio of their choice.

As an aside, am I the only person to notice that every time a renter posts these kinds of articles they always talk about how down the road they'll have enough money to buy a mortgage-payer's home but they never actually bother to mention how their investments have been doing for them in the meantime? I suspect there's an obvious reason for the omission.

Re:The Renter’s Manifesto by mechanical_fish on Sunday April 18, 2010 @02:06AM (#1274455)
they never actually bother to mention how their investments have been doing for them in the meantime

So, you're unhappy because other people don't use the same sort of anecdotal evidence that you are so fond of using yourself?

Who needs anecdotes when you have data? Here's a typical chart of median home prices since 1971, adjusted for inflation:

http://www.newfinancialwisdom.com/median-home-prices-inflati...

And here's a chart of the inflation-adjusted S&P500 since 1950 (skip down a few charts):

http://www.simplestockinvesting.com/SP500-historical-real-to...

What we see here is that, aside from some interesting but minor fluctuations and a scary but temporary blip representing last decade's bubble, housing prices are almost flat in real terms: The increase in median house price is almost equal to the inflation rate. Meanwhile, stock market investment values fluctuate a lot -- the last decade was not especially kind to investors -- but over the 1950-2008 time period the market averaged nearly 7% over inflation if you reinvest all dividends.

Now, you can get lucky. Or you can leverage insider knowledge: If you figure out that land in a certain area is systematically underpriced relative to future demand, you can make a killing without relying solely on luck. But the averages show that for every person who makes a killing in residential real estate, there's someone else who takes the equivalent bath. And note that the argument that "land in NYC/Northern California/Desirable Area X will keep growing in value because everyone wants to live there" presumes that the rest of the market hasn't already figured out that such land is more desirable and set prices accordingly.

Re:The Renter’s Manifesto by tpz on Sunday April 18, 2010 @02:25AM (#1274469)
For the record, I'm not unhappy at all, and if you'll look back at my original reply I was very up front about being just one data point.

You can get lucky. Or you can leverage insider knowledge. Or you can do some personal learning and invest wisely. All of these are equally applicable to investing in real estate or to investing in other things while being a renter. For some reason, however, those who profit from real estate are chalked up as lucky and those who profit from other things while renting seem to get to talk as if their success involved any less luck or any more informed investing. Why is this? In my case, I invested in a physical market in a particular region I had been watching for many years and which has generally steady indicators. I exited for entirely personal reasons (to live with my girlfriend, just to put it out there), not to "time" the market as claimed by one commenter who also claimed I got lucky. I was subsequently called out as unhappy by another - you. Again, why is this?

Any argument that can be made for or against success by an owner can be made equally well for or against success by a renter investing elsewhere, yet luck only gets cast towards the former, wisdom only towards the latter, and all the while the latter never seem to publish any of their investment success numbers to match their claims of benefit down the road. Again, why the disparity?

Whether in real estate or elsewhere, it's the same $500 per month during the same five years. Whether sourced from luck and/or expertise, why are one class of returns immediately disparaged while another goes entirely unstated yet entirely uncontested? I've never taken it as an offense personally, but do admit that it does seem to be a common pattern and not a particularly fair pattern, at that.

Re:The Renter’s Manifesto by sage_joch on Sunday April 18, 2010 @01:36AM (#1274420)
I've been debating whether to buy for about a year now, and you make an excellent point. For me, it boils down to the choice between a sense of freedom and a sense of home.
Re:The Renter’s Manifesto by prawn on Sunday April 18, 2010 @03:36AM (#1274527)
(Speaking from the Australian market, so there might be a few things that make the situation different for you.)

If you want to make major improvements or tweak your home, then home ownership beats renting. If you don't plan to live somewhere for more than five years (and transactional costs in buying and selling are harsh, as in South Australia), then renting could be your best option. If you lack financial discipline, then buying can beat a combination of renting and investing in shares.

Of course, you can always buy one place, rent it out and then rent another place yourself.

Re:The Renter’s Manifesto by timcederman on Sunday April 18, 2010 @12:52AM (#1274368)
I think renting does make more fiscal sense, but there are so many reasons to own your own place beyond finance.