Re:Donald Knuth used an Erlang-like notation
by old_sound on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @02:13AM
(#12741501)
Can we say: "If you understand the first 20 pages of TAOCP, you understand Erlang"?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Donald Knuth used an Erlang-like notation
by jacquesm on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @04:19AM
(#12742027)
You can understand Erlang even if you're not that good at math, but you won't be able to make much of TAOCP if you aren't good at math.
One thing is for sure: just trying to read TAOCP will eventually make you better at math.
Re:Donald Knuth used an Erlang-like notation
by old_sound on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @04:46AM
(#12742158)
There's no such thing as "being good at math". You either put effort and practice to learn it, or you don't. Fixed va Growth Mindset, etc…
Re:Donald Knuth used an Erlang-like notation
by JadeNB on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @11:43AM
(#12744772)
> There's no such thing as "being good at math". You either put effort and practice to learn it, or you don't.
I agree with your second sentence, and, as a mathematician and a teacher, I think that I agree with the spirit of the first, but I think that it's probably not worded as you mean. Think of the same sentence with, say, 'baseball' in place of 'math': I think that most people would agree with the second sentence, but not the first. By the same token, there's no such thing as "being inherently good" (or, for that matter, inherently bad) "at math"; but I think that it would be silly to pretend that the effort and practice don't make you good (or at least better) at it.
Re:Donald Knuth used an Erlang-like notation
by OskarS on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @05:28AM
(#12742335)
The thing about the beginning of Vol 1 of TAOCP is that it begins with the "mathematical preliminaries" which is among the most difficult things in the book (aside from some of the more hard-core analysis). Like, his description of heap-sort in Vol 3. is easy enough to follow, but fuck man, generating functions are hard!
Re:Donald Knuth used an Erlang-like notation
by Jtsummers on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @09:02AM
(#12743338)
Which is why my professor and classmate and I switched to Concrete Mathematics about halfway through working through chapter 1. More thorough examination of many of the topics in chapter 1, plus more material.
Re:Donald Knuth used an Erlang-like notation
by _asummers on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @07:04PM
(#12748484)
My advisor would always make a joke to his classes, when that book came up, that it had a dual purpose name - - that it was foundational, but also because it's hard as concrete. I used it as reference in some of my math classes but haven't given it a thorough read.
Re:Donald Knuth used an Erlang-like notation
by Jtsummers on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @09:22PM
(#12749231)
We worked through about 1/3 of the material starting one summer term (where we started on TAOCP) and finishing sometime in the fall. Definitely hard, but it also helped me finally understand a lot of math that I "knew" but hadn't yet grokked.