News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The secret to Farmville isn't gameplay or aesthetics by duck on Saturday April 17, 2010 @09:01PM (#1274082)
If Farmville is laborious to play and aesthetically boring, why are so many people playing it? The answer is disarmingly simple: people are playing Farmville because people are playing Farmville.

Very true from what I have seen. Nobody just starts playing something like Farmville unless someone else has asked them to.

It is kind of sickening to think about how much time is lost to crap like this.

Re:The secret to Farmville isn't gameplay or aesthetics by xsmasher on Saturday April 17, 2010 @11:37PM (#1274274)
>It is kind of sickening to think about how much time is lost to crap like this.

That's rather judgmental re: leisure time. Are you sickened by the time "lost" by people following or playing sports, or reading novels, or watching movies?

Re:The secret to Farmville isn't gameplay or aesthetics by neilk on Sunday April 18, 2010 @12:43AM (#1274361)
We can make judgments about leisure activities just as we can about any other part of life. Playing sports, reading novels, and watching (good) movies can all make you a healthier, more reflective person, while being intrinsically entertaining. Even WoW, while it has some disturbing aspects, has the wonder of exploring a fantasy world, online society, and some strategy.

I don't play Farmville but I don't know of anyone that argues it's time well spent. Players don't even seem to be having "fun" by any normal definition. At best, it exploits social rewards to make you conform to the game makers' agenda.

Perhaps it's closer to fashion than recreation; where you're on a consumption treadmill that's largely controlled by others. Without the consolation of having nice clothes or looking any better.

Re:The secret to Farmville isn't gameplay or aesthetics by robryan on Sunday April 18, 2010 @01:49AM (#1274430)
You would have to think farmville would have a high churn rate to, I played it casually for about a month before I realised there was little point continuing. Even some of the most dedicated amongst my friends eventually stopped after a few months. If anything the achievements in the game seemed to keep people coming back, even though some of them were just arbitrary large numbers of things done.

I don't think it is really a fun game at all which makes me think how successful a similar game would be if someone got the fun factor right, something like a civ for facebook or something.

Re:The secret to Farmville isn't gameplay or aesthetics by duck on Sunday April 18, 2010 @02:04AM (#1274453)
Yeah, but I think what we would consider fun would pretty much kill a game like Farmville in terms of popularity. I am only guessing... but your typical gamer is not playing Facebook.
Re:The secret to Farmville isn't gameplay or aesthetics by roundsquare on Monday April 19, 2010 @08:15AM (#1276527)
Unfortunately, fun usually involves the possibility of failure and trying to overcome it (at least with video games). Having a high chance of failure would probably ruin the games popularity.
Re:The secret to Farmville isn't gameplay or aesthetics by duck on Sunday April 18, 2010 @01:46AM (#1274427)
Nope, just apps/games/sites like Farmville (i.e. click games or maybe trance games?). As neilk said, the end result is not really 'fun' or learning. I know for a lot of people it is just something to pass the time, but there is so many other things that are productive like reading/watching where you either learn or feel something.

Maybe the easiest way to sum it up - I would not be sickened by anything that someone would enjoy telling me about. Tell me about a movie or book you like. Tell me about the the chess game you lost. Tell me about the five miles you ran. But if someone told me they clicked 20,000 times and enjoyed telling me that, I would call bull.

Re:The secret to Farmville isn't gameplay or aesthetics by adriand on Sunday April 18, 2010 @04:00AM (#1274536)
> I would not be sickened by anything that someone would enjoy telling me about.

This is actually an excellent test of the quality of a leisure activity and one I'd never considered. "And then, I clicked on the OTHER square, and a pumpkin grew THERE, too!" I just can't picture that.

Re:The secret to Farmville isn't gameplay or aesthetics by sliderr on Saturday April 17, 2010 @09:32PM (#1274120)
At least you noticed that you were wasting time. But the reason why people keep playing is not because of the others. The others are the reason why they start, they keep on playing because of the fake sense of achievement this game delivers. See Jessse Schells talk from DICE for details.
Re:The secret to Farmville isn't gameplay or aesthetics by watmough on Saturday April 17, 2010 @10:19PM (#1274180)
I call my wife Farmer Pixel because she's never off Farmville.

I've tried to get her to go out in the garden, but no avail!

Re:The secret to Farmville isn't gameplay or aesthetics by duck on Saturday April 17, 2010 @11:17PM (#1274242)
Yes, that sounds very familiar here as well. I don't know a single guy that plays it and that led me to search for male/female stats... but I only found that the average Farmville user is a 43-year-old woman (via http://www.npr.org/blogs/alltechconsidered/2010/02/this_aint...).
Re:The secret to Farmville isn't gameplay or aesthetics by watmough on Sunday April 25, 2010 @03:13AM (#1292322)
I have one friend (male) that plays these games, but he uses specially created accounts, and is motivated only by being able to mess with other players.
Re:The secret to Farmville isn't gameplay or aesthetics by ShardPhoenix on Saturday April 17, 2010 @09:28PM (#1274114)
The time isn't necessarily "lost" if it substitutes for other forms of human "social grooming".
Re:The secret to Farmville isn't gameplay or aesthetics by akkartik on Sunday April 18, 2010 @01:09AM (#1274391)
It's an interesting experiment to see how long you can try one of the zynga offerings without creating some sort of invitation to a friend. These guys have really squeezed the heck out of their viral loops.
Re:The secret to Farmville isn't gameplay or aesthetics by revorad on Sunday April 18, 2010 @06:41AM (#1274650)
It's the same reason why people are on Facebook in the first place, because well, people are on Facebook.