>Herein we report a common element, nanostructured catalyst for the direct electrochemical conversion of CO2 to ethanol with high Faradaic efficiency (63 % at −1.2 V vs RHE) and high selectivity (84 %) that operates in water and at ambient temperature and pressure.
I am not exactly sure how to understand the 63% efficiency but I assume that this is the rate of conversion from electrical to chemical energy.
However the conclusion of the article mentions that :
>The overpotential (which might be lowered with the proper electrolyte, and by separating the hydrogen production to another catalyst) probably precludes economic viability for this catalyst, but the high selectivity for a 12-electron reaction suggests that nanostructured surfaces with multiple reactive sites in close proximity can yield novel reaction mechanisms.
Which sounds much less optimistic that the article's headline.
So, no carbon scrubbing while feeding the world, but you could maybe scrub carbon by taking massive amounts of excess crops and burying/sealing them away. Not sure what the cost/efficiency of that would be.
As far as I know, the majority of net oxygen production happens through algae, because they die and sink to the bottom of the ocean, permanently removing carbon from the carbon cycle.
>Perhaps most importantly, it works at room temperature, which means that it can be started and stopped easily and with little energy cost. This means that this conversion process could be used as temporary energy storage during a lull in renewable energy generation, smoothing out fluctuations in a renewable energy grid.
Is it too much to ask that a science journal report on science in, like, quantitative terms to support a headline? Specifically: What's the efficiency (or how much energy is required per mole)? Estimated overall costs compared to batteries or grain ethanol? Other available chemical processes for capturing CO2, and their efficiency? Not reported. I have no idea what their arbitrary cut-off for "efficient" is, but if they say they want to make it more efficient, it obviously isn't efficient enough. Actual numbers might help to judge.