News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why the GNU Affero GPL by tzs on Saturday April 17, 2010 @01:22PM (#1273343)
A key aspect of GPL is that you trigger its source distribution requirement by doing something that requires permission of the copyright holder. This is key because it makes GPL fundamentally different from a EULA. As the FSF notes, licenses for proprietary software try to take away your freedoms, whereas GPL adds to them. This works because GPL only imposes requirements on you when you do something that the law otherwise disallows. The typical EULA tries to stop you from doing things the law otherwise allows.

If you obtain a legitimate copy of a GPL program and completely ignore the license, but only do things that copyright law allows you to do without needing the permission of the copyright holder, such as running the program, or making modifications to adapt it to run on your specific machine, you will not be in violation of the license--because the license only expands your copyright rights.

Affero GPL's requirement to distribute source is triggered by letting someone communicate with your running copy of the program. That's something that does NOT require the copyright owner's permission in copyright law. That's taking away a freedom we have under copyright law--and puts Affero GPL squarely in the EULA category.

The FSF seriously compromised their principles when they accepted Affero GPL.

Re:Why the GNU Affero GPL by loup-vaillant on Saturday April 17, 2010 @06:03PM (#1273813)
This is precisely because they compromised their principles with the AGPL that they didn't make it their main licence. They felt they had to let people make such a compromise, for some software.

The problem with software which have significant influence over the network is that it's "users" might not be the owners. Effectively, freedom 0 and the other three are in conflict. (My freedom to run the software is in conflict with your right to study it).

If I recall correctly, the FSF itself says AGPL software is not really free software.

Re:Why the GNU Affero GPL by blasdel on Saturday April 17, 2010 @08:09PM (#1274017)
Thank you! I've been making exactly this point over and over (http://searchyc.com/agpl+eula), it's nice to see someone else noticing the same bullshit.

Freedom Zero is the freedom to run the program, for any purpose