News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why the GNU Affero GPL by cperciva on Saturday April 17, 2010 @12:39PM (#1273272)
It keeps your code bona fide open source, so people who want to use and extend it noncommercially can do so without worrying about you at all; the code is genuinely free.

That depends on your definition of "bona fide open source". It's hard to understand how requiring that software contain certain features (as AGPL does) complies with the FSF's freedom #1 "to study how the program works and adapt it to your needs".

Re:Why the GNU Affero GPL by tptacek on Saturday April 17, 2010 @12:43PM (#1273277)
The FSF promotes free software, not open source software. Free software is a term with a somewhat rigorous definition. Open source, less so. Don't try to make my argument consistent with the FSF's. I don't care what the FSF thinks. I'm not a promoter of "free software".

Having said that, the AGPL helps ensure that software is kept open source by making it more difficult to take other people's open source code, extend it, and withholding the changes while profiting both from the original and the extensions. It's a pretty staightforward concept.

Re:Why the GNU Affero GPL by dfranke on Saturday April 17, 2010 @01:40PM (#1273372)
Open source is just as rigorously defined. http://opensource.org/docs/osd
Re:Why the GNU Affero GPL by halostatue on Saturday April 17, 2010 @01:32PM (#1273362)
In their official documents, the FSF keeps rigor in the definition of _free software_. In their informal communications, they're much less rigorous and start claiming all sorts of nonsensical things about what _software freedom_ means.
Re:Why the GNU Affero GPL by tptacek on Saturday April 17, 2010 @01:38PM (#1273370)
I disagree with what you're saying, but the Free Software Foundation is so irrelevant to my day-to-day life that it's not worth arguing with. I think a lot of the flack Stallman gets is that the lifestyle he advocates is repellant to people. I don't think that it has to do with him being inconsistent.
Re:Why the GNU Affero GPL by halostatue on Sunday April 18, 2010 @12:21AM (#1274325)
To clarify what I was intending to say, but didn't make as clear as I should have (I was posting from the iPhone).

1. RMS is incredibly consistent in what he says. He is a zealot in the best sense of the word. When he talks about software freedom, he always means the four freedoms, and he does his absolute hardest to never compromise his principles. This is (mostly) admirable[1], if infuriating because pragmatism would often get his arguments further IMO. However,

2. RMS is not the FSF, and not everyone who works with or for the FSF is as rigorous with their use of software freedom in discussions. When you step even further outside of the circle to those who support the FSF, the rigor is even less present.

So, what I didn't make clear in my excessively short initial reply was that I wasn't talking about RMS's lack of rigor; I was talking about the wider FSF circle.

[1] The whole "GNU/Linux" thing is one of the points where I think that the lack of compromise and zealotry is not admirable and demonstrates the same sort of negative zealotry that would be associated with a radical religious sect. It's great that RMS sticks to his guns, but sometimes he goes in directions that harm his position far more than if he were to compromise a little.

Re:Why the GNU Affero GPL by loup-vaillant on Saturday April 17, 2010 @05:28PM (#1273759)
"irrelevant to [your] day to day life"? Given the market share of Apache on GNU/Linux, I highly doubt it. I think the FSF has great (though indirect) influence even on you.

I think you are right about people being repelled by the lifestyle Stallman advocates. It's a pity.

Re:Why the GNU Affero GPL by tptacek on Saturday April 17, 2010 @05:54PM (#1273803)
Neither the Apache project nor Linux came to be because of the GPL. Had there been no GPL, they'd simply have used a different open license. But that's besides the point: what I'm saying is, I'm not particularly invested in the "four freedoms" perspective on software freedom.
Re:Why the GNU Affero GPL by loup-vaillant on Saturday April 17, 2010 @06:23PM (#1273852)
To the point: I understand. That sounds OK.

Besides the point: Don't forget the "GNU" in GNU/Linux. It came first. It is bigger. It made Linux (the kernel) possible, by doing the rest of the work. So, if you use Linux, remember that it comes with GNU.

PS: Apache doesn't use the GPL, by the way

Re:Why the GNU Affero GPL by tptacek on Saturday April 17, 2010 @06:51PM (#1273901)
You're obviously right about Apache (but then, why did you bring it up?).

But I disagree strongly about the "GNU/Linux" thing. Linux would have happened either way. I installed 386bsd off approximately seventeen thousand floppy disks when I was young, and I don't recall that being a GPL'd userland.

Re:Why the GNU Affero GPL by prodigal_erik on Saturday April 17, 2010 @07:09PM (#1273936)
Almost all the work during the Unix Wars was wasted, entombed in proprietary forks. It's no coincidence that they were all quickly surpassed by the first kernel whose license makes it mostly immune to that problem. Without the GPL, Linux would have happened just as slowly as the BSDs, and getting where we are would have taken many years (decades?) longer--and what's most appalling, most users would not be allowed to understand or improve their tools.
Re:Why the GNU Affero GPL by tuxychandru on Saturday April 17, 2010 @01:47PM (#1273387)
You are still free to study how an AGPL program works and adapt it to your needs. However, you just have to pass the same freedom to the users of your modified programs which means the source code must be available to them.

Also, if some of the adaptations you've made are liked by the original developer, he can integrate them into the main version. So both of you mutually benefit from each others work, rather than one just leeching on the other.