> Mere reasonable suspicion that all is not perfect in the subjective view of some official is nowhere close to sufficient to justify things like removing a child from a parent's care or separating an elderly married couple who have lived happily together for 60 years, in my not so humble opinion, yet I have read far too many stories that are disturbingly close to that in recent times.
> Given the realities, we must continue to look for new, innovative and better ways of handling these
cases, while never departing from the fundamentals, namely that:
> Care cases, with their potential for life‐long separation between children and their parents,
are of unique gravity and importance
> It is for the local authority to establish its case
> Common‐law principles of fairness and justice demand, as do Articles 6 and 8 of the Convention, a process in which both the parents and the child can fully participate with
the assistance of representation by skilled and experienced lawyers
As an example of how seriously the Family courts take their duty of involving children, here's one decision written so that the children can understand most of it:
https://www.judiciary.gov.uk/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/pfd-...
2005-6: 6613 cases
2014-15: 11159 cases
> Mere reasonable suspicion that all is not perfect in the subjective view of some official is nowhere close to sufficient to justify things like removing a child from a parent's care or separating an elderly married couple who have lived happily together for 60 years, in my not so humble opinion, yet I have read far too many stories that are disturbingly close to that in recent times.
Here's what Munby says:
https://www.judiciary.gov.uk/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/pfd-...
> Given the realities, we must continue to look for new, innovative and better ways of handling these cases, while never departing from the fundamentals, namely that:
> Care cases, with their potential for life‐long separation between children and their parents, are of unique gravity and importance
> It is for the local authority to establish its case
> Common‐law principles of fairness and justice demand, as do Articles 6 and 8 of the Convention, a process in which both the parents and the child can fully participate with the assistance of representation by skilled and experienced lawyers
As an example of how seriously the Family courts take their duty of involving children, here's one decision written so that the children can understand most of it:
http://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWFC/HCJ/2016/9.html