Re:Ask HN: Where do you go to read or watch neutral and unbi...
by giardini on Monday October 17, 2016 @01:59PM
(#12727457)
sycril correctly states
"...there was a study done that showed that if a knife man was armed and within 21 feet, he will be able to attack a gun man with the gun in the harness."
This is commonly referred to as the "Tueller Drill", after a trainer who first published the phenomenon:
Interpretations of Tueller's findings vary a great deal depending on the role one plays in an interaction and one's intent. For example, one might conclude that police should e.g., "shoot anyone within 21 feet who has a knife.", "One shot and they're out of action." or "Anyone outside of 21 feet and carrying a knife can be disregarded."
and so on. But those 3 statements are not necessarily true and one must analyze further:
It is quite astonishing how a simple experiment has revised thought about the old adage "Don't bring a knife to a gunfight!" Indeed it appears that within the 21 foot range, someone without a knife could be effectively unarmed (even if they have a gun).
"...there was a study done that showed that if a knife man was armed and within 21 feet, he will be able to attack a gun man with the gun in the harness."
This is commonly referred to as the "Tueller Drill", after a trainer who first published the phenomenon:
"How Close is Too Close?" by Dennis Tueller:
http://www.theppsc.org/Staff_Views/Tueller/How.Close.htm
Interpretations of Tueller's findings vary a great deal depending on the role one plays in an interaction and one's intent. For example, one might conclude that police should e.g., "shoot anyone within 21 feet who has a knife.", "One shot and they're out of action." or "Anyone outside of 21 feet and carrying a knife can be disregarded." and so on. But those 3 statements are not necessarily true and one must analyze further:
"Re-Thinking the 21-Foot Rule":
http://www.hendonpub.com/resources/article_archive/results/d...
"The Tueller Drill Myth: Why The 21 Foot Rule Isn’t a Rule At All":
http://www.itstactical.com/warcom/firearms/the-tueller-drill...
Google discussion of the Tueller Drill:
https://www.google.com/search?q=tueller+drill&client=opera&h...
It is quite astonishing how a simple experiment has revised thought about the old adage "Don't bring a knife to a gunfight!" Indeed it appears that within the 21 foot range, someone without a knife could be effectively unarmed (even if they have a gun).