News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fujifilm X-T2 review: for the love of photography by imaginenore on Monday October 17, 2016 @10:07AM (#12725102)
I'm a semi-pro photographer, do commercial work from time to time, get flown to shoot weddings across the globe.

$1600 is a ridiculous amount of money for this camera, considering the competition.

$1600-1700 buys you a used Sony A7s, the king of low light photography and video (if you don't count the new prototype from Canon), and it's full frame, unlike X-T2.

$1650 buys you a used Canon 5D mark III, which is also full frame, and is a great photo camera, which can also shoot RAW video with custom firmware.

Re:Fujifilm X-T2 review: for the love of photography by pizlonator on Monday October 17, 2016 @11:05AM (#12725599)
It depends on what is important to you. I like good UI and I will pay a premium for it. Fuji has the best UI - physical knobs for everything. Even ISO has a physical control. I find that UI makes a big difference for my workflow and makes it easier for me to take good pictures, so the price is worth it.

Also, I happen to use an X-Pro2 not the X-T2, but I think similar arguments apply.

Re:Fujifilm X-T2 review: for the love of photography by potatolicious on Monday October 17, 2016 @01:37PM (#12727217)
Agree - also an X-Pro 2 user, and the camera was worth every penny because ultimately (at least in this case) UX trumps technical capability.

The A7s is the undisputed low-light boss, but IMO Sony's UX is convoluted and too many features are buried behind too many menus.

At this point I see few reasons to worry much about spec sheets - every single camera, even small-sensor point-and-shoots - made right now are lightyears ahead of even the best 135 film cameras with the most exotic film back in the day.

Every modern crop-sensor body can shoot clean RAWs at ISO 6400, many shoot cleanly up to ISO 12,800. And what point do we accept these capabilities and focus on things that make it easier to get better photos?

The joystick on the back of the X-Pro 2 and X-T2 is a game changer, as are the advances in AF speed. I can nail shots purely by muscle memory, and that's great. The camera feels less like a thing I have to operate and more like an extension of my brain.

Re:Fujifilm X-T2 review: for the love of photography by KaiserPro on Monday October 17, 2016 @01:46PM (#12727306)
If you're a photographer you'll be needing maybe 5 controls:

ISO

Aperture

shutter speed

Metering mode

Autofocus point placement

Shutter and aperture might be automated away with different shooting mode. Even on Canons which I don't use often, I can bend it to my will, even if the buttons are in a "funny" place. I'm just not going to spend that much of a premium on a what is almost a repackaged phone sensor.

Everything else is literally noise.

The nikon d800, and canon or sony equivalent is the same price point. Not only that its full frame you can use real lens, but you get deep depth of field.

Re:Fujifilm X-T2 review: for the love of photography by rodgerd on Monday October 17, 2016 @02:49PM (#12728002)
> I'm just not going to spend that much of a premium on a what is almost a repackaged phone sensor.

One of the more spectacularly ignorant and stupid things I've read on HN, which is saying a lot.

> but you get deep depth of field.

Oh, right you don't actually know what you're talking about, you're just parroting talking points you read somewhere.

Re:Fujifilm X-T2 review: for the love of photography by KaiserPro on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:28PM (#12728560)
It is as they say, hyperbole.

Of course aps-c isn't a phone sensor, because making a monolith lens thin enough isn't worth it. (a lenticular array, maybe. But then who outside of VFX wants light field pictures?)

You are of course aware that sensor size and focal length directly affect the depth of field. Smaller sensor for the same focal length yields a wider depth of field. Yadda yadda field of view. This is why the stock lens 35 mm, because its about the same field of view as 50mm lens on a 35 mm sensor. (or why medium formats have ~80mm lens)

However, of course I'm just parroting that "from else where". Yup, no sir, no first hand experience at all.

Re:Fujifilm X-T2 review: for the love of photography by rodgerd on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @02:58AM (#12732637)
> It is as they say, hyperbole.

Was it a social experiment, as well?

> You are of course aware that sensor size and focal length directly affect the depth of field.

Yes, but it doesn't make it deeper on larger sensors, which is what you asserted.

Re:Fujifilm X-T2 review: for the love of photography by lb1lf on Monday October 17, 2016 @04:00PM (#12729043)
For most of the history of photography, you only had two (and a half) of those five at your disposal - shutter and aperture, the half being iso, which you effectively changed by using different films or pushing/pulling the exposure.

As others have already stated, the Fujis score big in UX - I'd like to add that their lenses are second to none.

As a long-term luddite (I own two digital cameras (A Nikon DSLR and a Fuji X100), but most of my shooting is done using either Fuji or Leica analog cameras), IMHO the camera is secondary - it is merely a light-tight box where you affix a lens at one end and the film at the other - the lenses are what matters.

Fuji makes some wonderful lenses. Resolution is awesome, contrast excellent and colour rendition best-in-business for those who care (I don't, I am colour blind - the last point is just parroting) - all in a (for the current mirrorless crop) in a very compact package (my GX680 lenses are somewhat less portable).

Fuji's current range can probably be accurately described as photographer's cameras - they've, just like Leica, distilled photography to its essentials and made their way to the front of that niche. Kudos!

Re:Fujifilm X-T2 review: for the love of photography by KaiserPro on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @03:13AM (#12732686)
Gotcha.

Now this is an argument that I was expecting. I was very seriously looking at the x100 when it came out. Precisely because it was styled to be a manual rangefinder.

I tried it, but I just didn't like the compromises. It felt like the rangefinder was a bit of a gimmick. The manual focus grid was non existent.

I loved that it was compact, but the quality wasn't quite up to the full frame, similar priced breatheren.

The only argument for it was the weight and compactness, which to me didn't matter all that much.

What I really wanted was a CCD insert for my olympus rangefinder (35 rd, poor man's noisy leica) However I suspect that ship has sailed.

Re:Fujifilm X-T2 review: for the love of photography by lb1lf on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @03:33AM (#12741819)
-Agreed on the X100; I tried one (An -s)for a few weeks, but found myself constantly comparing it to a 'real' rangefinder, probably not fair to the poor little thing, which IMHO is an excellent little camera, though a bit lacking in the manual focus department.

I've found - to my surprise - that I much prefer Sony's focus peaking when it comes to digital manual focus aids. It is responsive, accurate and much less obtrusive than I initially thought it would be. Still no beating a proper rangefinder, though (IMHO).

Oh well. It is my day off, it is lovely autumn weather outside and I've got a few rolls of Tri-X and Portra to expose. (In the Texas Leica - google the Fujica G690BL for a chuckle if you're not familiar with it)

Would love a CCD insert too, btw. :)

Re:Fujifilm X-T2 review: for the love of photography by rplst8 on Monday October 17, 2016 @01:57PM (#12727433)
> I'm just not going to spend that much of a premium on a what is almost a repackaged phone sensor.

A repackaged phone sensor??? I think you need to take another look at Fujifilm's APS-C sensor tech and image quality.

Re:Fujifilm X-T2 review: for the love of photography by jrockway on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @03:44AM (#12732764)
> I'm just not going to spend that much of a premium on a what is almost a repackaged phone sensor.

It's 21.3 iPhone 6 sensors. (Full frame is about 2 APS-C sensors.)

> Not only that its full frame you can use real lens, but you get deep depth of field.

Technically, cropping has absolutely nothing to do with depth of field. It's a depth-of-field to angle-of-view you're thinking about.

Re:Fujifilm X-T2 review: for the love of photography by KaiserPro on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @07:34AM (#12733506)
Depth of field is directly tied to focal length. The smaller the sensor, the smaller the focal length. Smaller focal length means deeper depth of field (ie more of the subject is in focus at a given f stop)
Re:Fujifilm X-T2 review: for the love of photography by hanklazard on Monday October 17, 2016 @10:29AM (#12725296)
Agreed, the price is way too high for this decent crop sensor camera. Many people like the aesthetic of the Fujis, including myself (I have an XT-1). In the end, the low-light performance and build quality of this great little camera just wasn't good enough and I got a refurb 5Diii body for about the price of this new model.

While certainly more limited than the selection for Canon, Fuji does have some really nice lenses for these X series cameras. The 23mm 1.4 (=35mm FF) is truly fantastic.

Re:Fujifilm X-T2 review: for the love of photography by rodgerd on Monday October 17, 2016 @02:51PM (#12728026)
> Agreed, the price is way too high for this decent crop sensor camera.

The price is lower than a 7D Mark II or a D500 (in my market).

The fixation with sensor size if ludicrous. I mean, if you want to spend as much on a 6D and deal with its bulk and shitty autofocus while trying to convince yourself you have a better camera, don't let me stop you. But you're in la-la land.

(And I don't even own, or want to own, a Fuji.)

Re:Fujifilm X-T2 review: for the love of photography by jrockway on Monday October 17, 2016 @11:23AM (#12725800)
I think the idea is that Fuji is specializing in smaller cameras. It's APS-C, so you get a smaller body and smaller lenses. If your primary mission is to photograph something, it doesn't really matter how big the camera is and the decision on what camera to use is all about semiconductor yield for the sensors ("full frame" is tiny, but easy to manufacture profitably). It's your primary mission so you'll bring whatever equipment you need to get the job done. This is a niche in the photography world; the vast majority of photographs are spur-of-the-moment cell phone photos, after all. Fujifilm sees more money in that market than specialist applications.

This camera isn't going to prevent the user from taking serious photographs. APS-C is big enough to capture plenty of data. I have a "1 inch" camera and really all 21 megapixels are usable at base ISO. The small size trades off the flexibility that an 8x10" camera gives you, but is easier to carry around. (It's harder to carry around than a phone, though, but provides vastly better images.)

As soon as you start moving into certain specialties in photography, certain models start making more sense. Wedding photography is about creating fine-art shots in a sports photography environment, so the professionals are using high-end "enthusiast" cameras to great effect. The autofocus gets almost every shot. The metering is always correct. Those cameras don't trade off speed for detail, so you can still make nice 8x10" enlargements that look fantastic (but maybe not take 30fps bursts as sports/photojournalism cameras might).

Other specialties are cost-constrained right now. Nobody wants to take their macro shots with a DSLR, but Phase One backs are $33,000 for your $10,000 view camera, and hobbyists don't have that much money. (It's even expensive for the pros, very much a pricing based on semiconductor yield rather than the time cost of not having one.) Hence they compromise by spending 8 hours in photoshop working around the limitations of their camera, or just use film.

If you don't care enough about the results to do either and are only going to buy one camera, an X-T2 is just as good as anything else. Carry it around to take excellent spur-of-the-moment shots, snap that nice landscape, use it at home to take some pictures of that bug you just killed. It's as good as anything else. (Upgrade to a D810 for a few more pixels and a lighter wallet.)

Re:Fujifilm X-T2 review: for the love of photography by wepple on Monday October 17, 2016 @11:05AM (#12725603)
> I'm a semi-pro photographer, do commercial work from time to time, get flown to shoot weddings across the globe.

I think this differentiates you fairly significantly from the target market of this camera.

By way of example, I'd take an X100T over your above suggestions, despite it being less expensive and not full-frame and having a few annoying quirks. I consider the way a camera integrates into your image-making process more important than low-light capability, pixel count, and couldn't give any less cares about video.

Re:Fujifilm X-T2 review: for the love of photography by dmark3 on Monday October 17, 2016 @10:40AM (#12725390)
The raw specs on the Sony are better, but the actual feel and handling of the Fuji X series is vastly superior.

BTW, the Provia and Velvia film simulations are stunning, IMHO.

Re:Fujifilm X-T2 review: for the love of photography by dagw on Monday October 17, 2016 @11:06AM (#12725621)
Agreed. I own an A7 and an X100s, and while the A7 is certainly a better and more versatile camera according just about any spec you care to use, the Fuji is the camera I grab before heading out 19 times out of 20.
Re:Fujifilm X-T2 review: for the love of photography by Lio on Monday October 17, 2016 @02:04PM (#12727526)
The X100 is a very special/quirky camera and that's easy to love despite any imperfections because it will let you do things other cameras can't. E.g. sync flash at > 1/1000

There's not many other cameras that will allow you to overpower day light if you don't want to lug a monoblock or multiple flash guns with you.

Re:Fujifilm X-T2 review: for the love of photography by xzez on Monday October 17, 2016 @10:56AM (#12725520)
The raw specs are objective can be clearly stated as superior. Handling and ergo is a subjective and largely personal preference. I'll agree that the Fuji X-T* has some better ergo, but to me the difference over the A7 is marginal and not at all vastly superior.
Re:Fujifilm X-T2 review: for the love of photography by xzez on Monday October 17, 2016 @10:33AM (#12725341)
My sentiments exactly.

I used a fuji X-E1 before I picked up my A7. I really enjoy the Fuji X series, but the prices are so close to the Sony A7 series that the extra expense is more than worth it for the clearly superior Sony FE system. I mean, the X-T2 is pretty much the same price as an A7ii.

I do love the build and feel of the Fuji XF lenses though, particularly the lenses that have the aperture ring.

Re:Fujifilm X-T2 review: for the love of photography by rplst8 on Monday October 17, 2016 @02:54PM (#12728055)
You might be right about the price. But for a lot less you can pick up a used X-E2 or X-T1 which are still fine cameras. The best part about any of them (including the X-T2) is you get access do Fujifilm's superior glass.

Their lenses are truly high quality lenses, on par with much more expensive stuff, though not the cheapest either.

Re:Fujifilm X-T2 review: for the love of photography by yesimahuman on Monday October 17, 2016 @01:29PM (#12727132)
I own an X-E2S and I think that model is even over priced. However, Fuji is becoming the Apple of cameras for consumers, and frankly their audience is happy to pay a bit more for a camera that fits the aesthetic they want while still being high quality and reputable.

If I was a pro, I'd be shooting Canon or Nikon, I don't think the Fujifilm line is worth switching to given that the slight benefits of a mirrorless don't make up for the drawbacks for pros, but I know many pros are very successful with them, so what do I know.

That being said, I love my Fujifilm and take it everywhere. It's a leica without leica cost, and that's exactly what I wanted.

Re:Fujifilm X-T2 review: for the love of photography by rplst8 on Monday October 17, 2016 @02:00PM (#12727464)
> I own an X-E2S and I think that model is even over priced.

> I love my Fujifilm and take it everywhere. It's a leica without leica cost, and that's exactly what I wanted.

I don't know how you can rectify those two statements.

P.S. Leica is the Apple of the photography world.

Re:Fujifilm X-T2 review: for the love of photography by yesimahuman on Monday October 17, 2016 @02:05PM (#12727535)
Leica is leica, there's not really an analog in the tech world. I can't remember the last time I dropped $10k on a starter computer system or device, Apple or otherwise (which would be a Lieca M body with Leica glass today).

Fujifilm price points are much more Apple-like.

Re:Fujifilm X-T2 review: for the love of photography by lb1lf on Monday October 17, 2016 @04:22PM (#12729306)
Leica, IMHO, is pretty much the Rolex of the camera world.

While arguably 'the best' if you choose your criteria narrowly enough, their strongest selling point nowadays is the Veblen factor - they are seen as something special, the pinnacle, the yardstick competitors are measured against. Same goes for Rolex - while making excellent watches, there's hardly any denying that the competition is just as competent at a vastly less unreasonable price point.

(Full disclosure - I am a long-time Leica enthusiast, but I've long abandoned their cameras for (to me) more sensible options - I use a Zeiss Ikon ZM (Made by Cosina) with Leica lenses. The ZM is more rugged, arguably has a better rangefinder and is less idiosyncratic than any Leica body. Just try loading a film in an ZM versus a Leica, for starters)

Re:Fujifilm X-T2 review: for the love of photography by et-al on Monday October 17, 2016 @01:01PM (#12726851)
It's a niche camera. I wouldn't recommend it for anyone starting out in photography, but for someone who values the ergonomics of film cameras, I think Fujis may suit their needs better than the Sony or Canon you mentioned.

It's like buying a Subaru BR-Z in 2016. There are other cars that perform better, but sometimes it's the experience of using something in a particular fashion that brings the most joy.