Some of these articles are implying a size of an effect that is completely ridiculous, there is just no way that diversity "could increase revenue by 41%" - we'd see way more diversity in work places if this was true. Here is an article with a different conclusion - and here the "educational diversity" only had a more reasonable 2% effect, while "demographic diversity" is allegedly harmful [1]. But you have to be careful, all of these studies appear to suffer from testing multiple hypothesis - breaking diversity down into sub-categories and looking at each one independently should decrease confidence in the conclusions of these studies.
> Some of these articles are implying a size of an effect that is completely ridiculous, there is just no way that diversity "could increase revenue by 41%" - we'd see way more diversity in work places if this was true.
This seems to be rejecting data and substituting and a handwave. From the original study, 41% is the actual coefficient, controlling for a ton of things. Likely there are latent factors that make workplaces both gender-diverse and performant, so just swapping out half of a workplace would not hit all of these, which the paper acknowledges. We are seeing more diversity thanks to studies like these and explicit diversity initiatives, but given all of the biases that can exist in hiring pipelines, I can't think of any reason why it would happen naturally.
The paper you link is trying to measure firm productivity (could not 100% figure out what this means) based on data from Denmark, mainly non-white-collar jobs. It notes that demographic diversity promotes "better problem-solving abilities and more creativity and knowledge spillover" and can be a "substantial competitive advantage", limited by people not trusting/communicating with each other (i.e. integrating effectively).
It does seem like age-based discrimination would have a negative effect on psychological safety, as with any discrimination due to conscious or unconscious biases. Regarding perspective, an experienced individual could either bring in valuable insight from their experience or constantly veer towards the status quo, partly depending on how you want to look at it.
I think the answer is: it is complicated. You now have my ideas on why diversity is valuable. Does age fit that model? (Even if not, of course, age-based discrimination is not good.)
[1] https://news.mit.edu/2014/workplace-diversity-can-help-botto... [2] http://www.nytimes.com/2016/02/28/magazine/what-google-learn... [3] https://hbr.org/2013/12/how-diversity-can-drive-innovation [4] https://www.fastcompany.com/1841060/redefining-diversity-new... - bonus