News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Peter Thiel to Donate $1.25M in Support of Donald Trump by morgante on Sunday October 16, 2016 @12:43AM (#12716988)
> I didn't know about Brendan Eich. That makes me angry.

It makes me angry too, but also raises (for me) some interesting political questions around what level of disagreement is "too far." I would never fire someone for being a Republican and personally/privately opposing gay marriage. But I would also immediately fire someone if they were a Nazi. So where is the line if what's an acceptable level of tolerance (and where does Trump fall on it)?

Re:Peter Thiel to Donate $1.25M in Support of Donald Trump by josinalvo on Sunday October 16, 2016 @12:21PM (#12719325)
I'll just repost an old comment, advocating that the limit is: is it speech and ideas? Then do not fire.

"I fundamentally disagree with you about this very important issue, and we should still find a way to cooperate" is a crucial idea, hard won and, as we are seeing, easily lost. It underpins multi-religious societies, working democracies, and in general, any group of people that need to do something. Unfortunately, right now we have groups of people that say the polar oposite: "It is good and moral to shun people who disagree with X".

I totally agree with marriage equality. But I think it can be (and mostly was) won on dialogue, not shunning. And I will always be against the shunners (though I hope not to shun them :P).

btw, all I just said applies just as well to klanspeople/nazis: Are they harming the employees? No? Are they aligned with the mission? Them keep them. And tell them they are stupid over a beer. Talk the shit out, and fight their stupid ideas in the right places. Do not allow political disagreement, even of the most grievous kind, to cut oportunities for dialogue and cooperation.

Re:Peter Thiel to Donate $1.25M in Support of Donald Trump by morgante on Sunday October 16, 2016 @08:05PM (#12721826)
> is it speech and ideas? Then do not fire.

How far will you take that principal though?

What if you have an employee who consistently comes in and talks about how he'd like to kill all the non-white people? What if he talks about how many guns he has? I think this would make the office an unworkable environment for most of my other employees (particularly any PoC) and I would be very justified in firing them.

Re:Peter Thiel to Donate $1.25M in Support of Donald Trump by ubernostrum on Sunday October 16, 2016 @02:36AM (#12717316)
So consider Proposition 8. This was a ballot measure whose sole purpose was to enshrine in law the idea that "this group of people over here aren't legally equal to everyone else".

Privately believing someone has done something wrong, or belongs to a bad group, is one thing. Trying to enshrine that belief in law and disenfranchise the targeted person or group is quite another thing, and if you honestly are unable to see the difference between the two I'm unsure how to assist you.

Re:Peter Thiel to Donate $1.25M in Support of Donald Trump by paulv on Sunday October 16, 2016 @04:13AM (#12717582)
Look at the timeline. Eich donated after Prop 22 was overturned (Prop 22 restricted marriage to same-sex couples). He wasn't trying to keep the status quo, he was trying to change the California constitution to outlaw something that the court had previously deemed legal. The end result of that difference is subtle, yes, but I find the spirit of the difference significant. Which is to say...much worse.
Re:Peter Thiel to Donate $1.25M in Support of Donald Trump by BrendanEich on Sunday October 16, 2016 @08:28PM (#12721928)
I wrote something too long about your confused post (for example, you must have meant "opposite-sex", not "same-sex"), then set it aside. I'll just note that of course I supported Prop 8 after the California Supreme Court overturned Prop 22 in its May, 2008 "In re Marriage Cases" ruling. Prop 8 was not even on the ballot until June, 2008!

Your argument that my support was pernicious is based on bogus chronology.

As for "status quo", that was exactly the issue, or one of two big issues. Judges do not make law, they are not our dictators, not even in extremis. It's up to the people and the legislature to correct course, based on judicial review and judicial nullification at the limit, but with new law coming from the legislature and the ballot initiative process (in California, anyway).

A lot of us in California supported Mark Leno's work over more than a decade prior to 2008 to enact CA Domestic Partner law, precisely to address injustices, even as Leno, et al. did not attempt to redefine marriage. That we saw judicial overreach and moved against it does not make us opponents of the status quo.

(Speaking of status quo, Prop 22's definition of marriage is still in the California constitution: http://www.leginfo.ca.gov/.const/.article_1 SEC. 7.5.)

If you think courts should rule us, just wait long enough. The "next Trump" may give you the judges you deserve. I sincerely commend rule of law and judicial restraint to your attention, even if you don't agree with me on anything else.

Re:Peter Thiel to Donate $1.25M in Support of Donald Trump by sjellis on Sunday October 16, 2016 @05:30AM (#12717784)
Thank you - I think that is the thing that pro-Eich people consistently ignore. The Prop 8 campaign to retroactively strip people of human rights once those rights were re-affirmed by the state Supreme Court was an act of pure malice and spite. I don't know what Eich's personal reasons for donating were, but it speaks very poorly of his character that he did.
Re:Peter Thiel to Donate $1.25M in Support of Donald Trump by BrendanEich on Sunday October 16, 2016 @08:19PM (#12721891)
> to retroactively strip

Prop 8 would not and did not "nullify" any marriages licensed by the state in the middle of 2008. See

http://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/Prop-8-not-retroactive...

Retroactive or ex-post-facto law is unconstitutional. I am a big fan of this principle. It protects all of us.

> it speaks very poorly

Speaking ill of me based on false information does not reflect well on you. Let's back off and perhaps we'll meet on better terms another day. (FYI, I do not support Trump.)

Re:Peter Thiel to Donate $1.25M in Support of Donald Trump by morgante on Sunday October 16, 2016 @02:39AM (#12717325)
> Privately believing someone has done something wrong, or belongs to a bad group, is one thing.

Did I say they were the same thing? I absolutely think that "let's make gay marriage illegal" is categorically worse than "I don't like gay marriage."

As bad a Prop 8 was, the policies Trump advocates are 1,000 times worse, yet I don't see anyone working to boycott or quit his companies.

Re:Peter Thiel to Donate $1.25M in Support of Donald Trump by ubernostrum on Sunday October 16, 2016 @02:50AM (#12717358)
As I walked home from work yesterday I was listening to a podcast about economics which mentioned that the Trump brand has been permanently devalued by his campaign -- people no longer want to stay in a Trump hotel, for example. And people have been leading efforts to drive potential students away from his "Trump University", and potential customers away from his other businesses.

It's possible you haven't seen such efforts, but that is not identical with "no efforts are occurring".

Re:Peter Thiel to Donate $1.25M in Support of Donald Trump by morgante on Sunday October 16, 2016 @02:57AM (#12717383)
I've definitely heard about direct economic effects for Trump (though I think he'll end up gaining a lot more economically from the massive diehard fanbase he has now built) but why hasn't there been more backlash against Thiel? In my book his cause is a whole lot worse than Eich's.

Would you feel comfortable working at Peter Thiel's company?

Re:Peter Thiel to Donate $1.25M in Support of Donald Trump by ubernostrum on Sunday October 16, 2016 @03:12AM (#12717432)
I would not work for Thiel.

Also there are people pressuring, for example, pg to dump his association with Thiel.

Re:Peter Thiel to Donate $1.25M in Support of Donald Trump by ebfe on Sunday October 16, 2016 @12:48PM (#12719505)
Out of curiosity, do you also oppose non-flat taxation, affirmative action, minority-owned business contracting priorities, etc.?
Re:Peter Thiel to Donate $1.25M in Support of Donald Trump by ubernostrum on Sunday October 16, 2016 @08:22PM (#12721907)
Non-flat taxation are an attempt to make the impact of the law be equal on everyone.

Affirmative action is an attempt to alleviate the impact of prior laws and practices which made people unequal.

I am generally fine with trying to redress previously-enforced inequalities, and suspicious of anyone who isn't (protip: Google "libertarianism, starting right now" for an explanation of why this is important that you're more likely to agree with if a "LOL look how hard I rekt that dude by shoving affirmative action in his face" type sound-bite is the first thing you reach for in this kind of discussion)

Re:Peter Thiel to Donate $1.25M in Support of Donald Trump by metamicah on Sunday October 16, 2016 @01:18AM (#12717095)
Maybe it's just practicality: there's not much business sense in having leaders that publicly work against some of the most deeply meaningful interests of a significant portion of their employees.
[dead]
Re:Peter Thiel to Donate $1.25M in Support of Donald Trump by morgante on Sunday October 16, 2016 @01:22AM (#12717108)
> Is Nazism really that bad?

Yes. Please take your Holocaust apologia elsewhere.

Killing millions of people for no other reason than that you don't like their ethnicity is pretty much the baseline of immorality. Heck, killing millions of people for more legitimate reasons (being Nazis) also would be pretty abhorrent.

Also, for the record, "we" are not generally okay with senseless wars. There's a reason that murdering innocent civilians is considered a war crime.