Wouldn't it make more sense to query the school system to see if the laptop is flagged as stolen before using the camera?
Hmmm, I suppose from that viewpoint you'd also want to follow their policy of not telling anyone about the security system in the first place.
That's the failure in that logic. "Purely from a security viewpoint," it would make sense to strip all airline passengers naked and force them to stow all their luggage/clothes (i.e. no carry-ons), and have armed security agents staring them down the entire flight.
I.e. if you were to use it outside of the context of a school, there's still the possibility a minor might steal your laptop, set it up in his bedroom, have legal (for him and her) XXX with another minor....
In the above case I think you haven't broken the spirit of US child porn laws (that they are born illegal because they can't be taken without hurting the minor(s) in question), but I could be wrong. Legally your case is much iffier. Morally it's stronger, but how much so?
As I recall from my interpretation of what the school's sysadmin said (and perhaps others), when the system connects to the net and it's not the normal LAN, it automatically starts taking pictures and sending those, screen shots and the usual (IP address etc.) to the school's servers. But I may be wrong.
ADDED: But I'm pretty sure I'm right, these are Macs with their hardwired "camera on" lights. Which many students noticed blinking and were assured was merely a "glitch". At least according to many accounts ... I guess we'll find out in the upcoming trials.
"Activated" in that context is using the theft server software to look at that already stored info. The only question then would be if administrators also looked at the pictures in one way or another outside of the scope of a "stolen" or whatever laptop.
Whichever, it sounds like some of the were having a little too much fun spying on their charges. Which should have told them something....
WRT 1: There's the theory that laptop use in the classroom is good. I think this is bogus (it's been much discussed in general) but they were working on that theory. Laptops also allow work to be completed away from fixed workstations, including obviously in this case at home. Use of the laptops was mandatory for various classes.
WRT 2: They did require some sort of collateral or payment, but still had situations where a laptop was out there without it. I think this lawsuit is one of those cases, or they are now claiming so.