I am sorry, but I fail to see how offering https support as a premium feature could be considered "shady".
All web traffic should be encrypted, regardless of purpose. This increases the work that nation-state level adversaries must do to effectively spy on the population. And it's cheap and easy to do these days.
It's not a question if its easy to do or not. Yes I prefer an encrypted connection over one that is not.
BUT! the point here is the op claims this is a shady practice to provide https to their paying customers.
A shady practice is if they take your personal information and sell it to another without telling you. Shady is when companies lie to their customers.
And this situation is not.
Also, Pastebin has some shady practices. One example: they offer HTTPS support as a premium feature.