News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hyperloop One Raises $50M, Hires Former Uber CFO by trhway on Friday October 14, 2016 @02:39PM (#12710204)
>I still can't get past the feeling that this is another Moller Aircar type project. Something to string investors along forever while you bilk them out of money.

i wonder why such animosity toward Moller. His approach on the last incarnation of the car has some technical mistakes which made it a dead end, yet looking into his history and the overall history of VTOL i wonder how people may see that as a scam. It is pretty obvious today that we will have human carrying 8/12/16-copters in the next few years (we actually already have them as actually flying prototypes today) and that is pretty much where Moller was in 198x-199x just adjusting for the non-availability of modern hardware and electronics back then (so he went for complicated double-engine-same-shaft design with minimum of controlling electronics - the approach which doomed the last incarnation. I do fail to see a scam here.)

Re:Hyperloop One Raises $50M, Hires Former Uber CFO by Animats on Friday October 14, 2016 @05:01PM (#12711064)
Moller makes the same claims over and over, and adjusts the proposed completion date on the web site year after year to be about three years in the future. (Long discussion of this on the Wikipedia talk page.) He's been in trouble with the SEC for overclaiming to investors. His product has been "real soon now" since the 1970s. Here's his 1974 brochure.[1] Full-scale production was to begin by the end of 1976.

Moller was trying to build a VTOL powered by Wankel engines. His company was trying to build Wankels with much better power to weight ratios than usual. As usual, this resulted in much reduced engine lifespan. (Classic tradeoff, as everybody in drag racing knows.) He's been able to build a vehicle that can get off the ground, and hover a bit, tethered from a crane, for 2-3 minutes.

Pure-thrust VTOL is quite possible with jet engines. The aircraft that do it, such as the Harrier and the F-35, are fighters, which are mostly engine anyway. It can be done, but not at low cost or high payload or high efficiency.

Jet engines remain expensive. Despite many attempts, small, cheap, reliable jet engines remain out of reach. Below 6-passenger bizjet size, reliable engines don't seem to get much cheaper. There are cheap high-powered small jet engines with model aircraft levels of reliability and a life of 100 hours or so. That's how the Flyboard Air does it.[2] Not being stupid, they always fly this over water at low altitudes.

[1] http://www.downside.com/scams/moller/ [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KEDrMriKsFM

Re:Hyperloop One Raises $50M, Hires Former Uber CFO by jandrese on Friday October 14, 2016 @02:59PM (#12710319)
> i wonder why such animosity toward Moller.

50+ years and $100m in R&D no viable prototypes might have something to do with it.

Maybe the approach was doomed from the start, but that didn't stop Moller from promising that you would be commuting to work by air in 10 years for decade after decade.

Re:Hyperloop One Raises $50M, Hires Former Uber CFO by trhway on Friday October 14, 2016 @03:50PM (#12710609)
>50+ years and $100m in R&D

tell this to fusion guys :)

>no viable prototypes

i find this for example as looking very viable back at the time

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3MwxVAZuFOs

and actually if you add more props (possible with electric today not so much with gas engines back then) and much-much better control electronics you'll get the modern multi-copters :

volocopter prototype https://youtu.be/L75ESD9PBOw?t=97 and pre-production https://youtu.be/VAEy0NltoFQ?t=78

>Maybe the approach was doomed from the start, but that didn't stop Moller from promising that you would be commuting to work by air in 10 years for decade after decade.

only the last one, m400 was doomed as i mentioned above (and it wasn't actually that clear from the start, m400 was actually pretty logical and reasonable move forward - only after first tests one could see it clear). Put yourself at his place at any point in the history of his flying car development and those 10 years would look like a reasonable estimate. I personally actually say today that in 5 years we'll have the Volocopter likes flying around.

Re:Hyperloop One Raises $50M, Hires Former Uber CFO by TeMPOraL on Friday October 14, 2016 @04:27PM (#12710848)
> >50+ years and $100m in R&D

> tell this to fusion guys :)

Drop the "50+ years" and tell it to every other SV startup these days... ;).

Re:Hyperloop One Raises $50M, Hires Former Uber CFO by JKCalhoun on Friday October 14, 2016 @06:53PM (#12711685)
The animosity may be more toward the impracticality of throwing huge volumes of fuel (generating untold pollution) at a rich man's problem.
Re:Hyperloop One Raises $50M, Hires Former Uber CFO by jandrese on Friday October 14, 2016 @08:41PM (#12712082)
I don't think so. Even if they were built the aircars would cost around half a million each. Nobody cares that much about the fuel burn on a product that only a few hundred people would ever own.

Plus, they would spend most of the time in the shop anyway. Moller's big idea was to design an engine that was cheap, lightweight, had a very high power to weight ratio, efficient, and extremely reliable. For some reason he has had trouble making an engine that ticks all of the boxes.