Since most everything we do today involves computers and the internet, wire fraud has become a catch-all charge that can be selectively enforced (see Aaron Swartz) to suit a prosecutor's needs.
Despite the fact that many large players spoof on a regular basis, only this guy has been actually criminally charged. When a government anointed HFT firm does it, they only get a small slap on the wrist. Ironically, this guy pointed out to regulators how everyone is spoofing, and only after they did nothing to stop the spoofing did he say "well if everyone is doing it, I will too".
The corrupt financial elite have found their scapegoat, and the message is clear: if you're a connected Wall Street firm, the laws do not apply to you, but if you're a regular guy day trading from home, the book will be thrown at you.
Key quote: "This manipulative practice [spoofing] is illegal under the U.S. securities law, yet it has been frequently discovered in both equity and futures markets."
Here's an example of the penalty a middling HFT firm sees: http://www.reuters.com/article/us-sec-enforcement-spoofing-i...
$1.9M in fines - no jail. By contrast Sarao is facing up 380 years in prison.
Others faced fines of only several hundred thousand dollars: http://www.wsj.com/articles/how-spoofing-traders-dupe-market...
Note that the most connected HFT firms (Virtu, Citadel - oh hey, Ben "Revolving Door" Bernanke works there) don't even get fines, despite engaging in spoofing, and even being banned from China for spoofing: https://www.ft.com/content/d4b61458-398d-11e5-8613-07d16aad2...
Also note that there have been many "flash crashes" triggered by spoofing HFT's. There's nothing special about the Sarao one, other than the fact that he was an individual operating out of his home.
Furthermore, the study is based on the premise that there is lots of spoofing going on. That's because EVERYONE knows that spoofing is rampant. Everyone has acknowledged it, including the SEC and the Fed, so to dismiss the study by simply saying "it used fake data" with no other context is not a forthright appraisal of the situation.
That's fine, but you can't then claim the study as evidence of spoofing, since it was injected into the simulations explicitly.
> which they then compare to real data to test its accuracy, which they claim is 90%
The validation with real data was just comparing things like trade volume, volatility, autocorrelation, etc. They didn't put a specific number on it (the 90% accuracy mentioned in the abstract is about detecting HFT in simulated data). And they added in the spoofing after the validation.
There definitely is spoofing going on (some of my job involves trying to detect it), but I'm deeply skeptical of anyone who claims they can detect it accurately or quantify the amount. 92% accuracy for detecting spoofers in simulated data is insanely high, and makes me doubt the applicability to the real world.
It doesn't seem unusual at all to me that someone charged with fraud in US markets would get extradited to the US.