The core issue is the idea of mingling "underprivileged" kids with "privileged" ones; with intuitive expected result being some "lifting up" of the underprivileged kids at the expense of some of the education of the privileged kids.
Except there's no evidence this helps the underprivileged kids. There's lot of evidence it completely screws over the privileged kids and the end result is a dumpster fire of social engineering proportions. It's why we don't try to do it anymore, and every new generation needs to be taught the lesson lest they repeat it.
My siblings, 6 of us brought up on feeding pigs and making hay and fixing fences, all ended up going to college in medicine and engineering. All professionals; all successful. I always credited our going to school with all those 'city kids' with their high expectations.
So it can work.