Re:You might not need JavaScript
by Sir_Cmpwn on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @05:15AM
(#12691420)
You should surely realize that requiring SCSS and requiring JS are two very different concerns.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:You might not need JavaScript
by BinaryIdiot on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @05:28AM
(#12691470)
Of course they're different but the article mentions JavaScript as a dependency. SCSS would also be a dependency it just comes into the stack at a different place but it's there nonetheless.
Regardless my other points still stand.
SCSS is not a dependency for the user, this gets rid of the requirement of having JS and having it enabled and any page that works without JS is a better page than one that requires it.
One is a server-side depencency and one is a client-side dependency. Don't conflate them.
SCSS isn't even server side, it's developer side. Your build pipeline can be ugly as sin, the client should never care.
Until you need to maintain it (small changes) or worse, (breaking) change it. I'm not going to trade a flexible js dep for a limited css trick.
Re:You might not need JavaScript
by BinaryIdiot on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @01:13PM
(#12694705)
I never did conflate them. I've worked in this industry for 12 years now. I really don't get the disconnect here. I called it a dependency because it is and everyone is trying to tell me it's a different type of dependency. Well no shit but that was never my point to begin with.
My point was hijacked and contorted here.
What everyone's trying to tell you is that your point is beside the point.
Re:You might not need JavaScript
by BinaryIdiot on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @03:23PM
(#12695740)
The dependency thing was a minor quip at the start, it was never the point...the other 70% of the text was the point and unrelated to my dependency comment. I don't see anyone trying to say that, these comments seem as if my quip was the entire point of my post.
Talk about a tangent over a tiny, unremarkable comment that was meant to be light hearted.