News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amid debate, all 2016 American Nobel laureates are immigr... by mc32 on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @09:13AM (#12684036)
There is a difference between legal immigrants, illegal immigrants, immigrants with advanced education and immigrants with low levels of education. To evaluate the contribution of all of them together and say that the are the same is like taking a look at all Americans and saying, Americans are doing great, look at our per capita income.

There is a debate to be had about who and how and how many people from where we allow to settle. We are outliers in how many people we take in. And I think we should tailor policies with the impact on Americans in mind.

We're no longer in a steep growth phase, we're a mature economy which can successfully absorb so many new people into viable jobs. We need to work harder to get our underemployed better employed before we employ the surplus workers from elsewhere.

That's not to say no immigration. Just controlled and proportional to need and population of origin so that both a Senegalese and Indian and Cuban have reasonable equality in obtaining a visa.

There is no reason we can't set data driven quotas to allow, say, 2MM per annum to fill needs for ditch diggers and doctors, etc. But base it on need and do it with some balance.

Re:Amid debate, all 2016 American Nobel laureates are immigr... by golemotron on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @09:24AM (#12684120)
The Overton Window on immigration is fascinating. We've gone from being a nation that that had selective immigration all through its history to one where trying to halt illegal immigration gets you labeled a xenophobe and a racist.

Social media has made it worse. I think that it encourages preference falsification and causes inelasticity in the Overton Window. That inelasticity means that changes in public opinion are abrupt and usually need some concrete excuse to be justified.

Re:Amid debate, all 2016 American Nobel laureates are immigr... by ardit33 on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @10:14AM (#12684521)
That is not true, not for the first 100+ years at least. Until 1882, if you could afford the ticket to the US, you could come. So, at the time relatively expensive travel costs were the barrier of immigration, but not laws.

"The Page Act becomes law. It's the country's first exclusionary act, banning criminals, prostitutes, and Chinese contract laborers from entering the country. 1882. Congress passes the Immigration Act."

Re:Amid debate, all 2016 American Nobel laureates are immigr... by TorKlingberg on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @09:37AM (#12684210)
Yes, but hostility towards one group of immigrants often bleeds over into hostility towards immigrants in general.
Re:Amid debate, all 2016 American Nobel laureates are immigr... by mc32 on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @10:25AM (#12684614)
That's definitely a problem. Civilians should not be in the business of meting out retribution, however just they may think it is.

That said, I think if the US had a strict policy like any number of countries where you can presume 90%+ of immigrants are legal, people would treat immigrants much better knowing they didn't shortcut the system, they have government imprimatur and that they contribute to the economy and to other Americans' wellbeing.

Re:Amid debate, all 2016 American Nobel laureates are immigr... by adiabatty on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @03:22PM (#12687670)
Can you show how, say, a hostility to uneducated Latin Americans would bleed over to upper-middle-class Chinese immigrants and their descendants?
Re:Amid debate, all 2016 American Nobel laureates are immigr... by mc32 on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @03:29PM (#12687731)
It's less likely because professionals have a. different options when job pressures arise, b. usually opt for civil options to address shortcomings. So, by the nature of the demographics, the reaction to jobs pressures will be different.

But... regardless, we should always proceed civilly and petition the gov't rather than lash out on a population, legal or not.

For example, in England /UK we witness outlash toward Poles, despite their not being outwardly different, but for language. Again, lower classes feel undue labor pressure and take it out on working class immigrants.