News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amid debate, all 2016 American Nobel laureates are immigr... by punazj on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @07:34AM (#12683350)
Because of capitalism I think, you can't just appropriate someone's profits, that's not capitalism.

There are two basic ideas to solve this though, you can put more and more taxes on the capital owning class to "make them pay their fair share" for, from what I gather the humanists want, an unlimited number of economic migrants because it's the human thing to do. Now an important thing to note, might be Trump's comments in the second debate, that while everyone is going on about how he legally avoided paying maximal amounts of taxes (which I would do as well, I think most everyone pays as little tax as they legally can), Hillary's donors also use those loopholes. It takes a lot more research into the respective tax plans to see if "making the rich pay their fair share" is a campaign line or an actual plan, so that takes checking.

I gather that the arguments against this are that if people can't be rich in the USA, they will go be rich somewhere else. The USA, from Trump's rhetoric, I haven't checked this, has some of the higher corporate tax rates in the world, and seeing as how manufacturing has already spread outside the USA, is it really crazy to assume the capital will as well (especially when selling the goods to America is facilitated by free trade deals that are in place, making it less costly to move your business to another country).

This is the Democratic party tack to deal with wealth inequality.

The second plan is to cause a shortage of labor, which would increase it's value, which would make wages go up. The common ways to do this would be: to make it expensive to import goods into America (which lessens the effect of labor in foreign factories which export into the USA) by getting rid of free trade agreements; and to lower the number of people in the USA competing for that labor. We attempt to do this by having an immigration procedure, with quotas, so that we can accept as immigrants into our labor force the number of people needed at various skill levels (this would be why it's easier for a doctor to get in than a farmer, say). Trump's "wall" is basically just a way to say "we should enforce the quotas that our immigration experts are setting so that our labor force isn't glutted by excess supply in any relative tier".

This is the republican tack to tackle wealth disparity.

The arguments against this are mostly humanitarian, from what I gather. A significant portion of the population consider's it America's duty and legacy to be the harbor for the indigent. There's also arguments for cultural enrichment etc.

I think that's why so much emotion is involved in opposing it, and why so much backlash is rightfully indignant and angry. One side is hurt by this betrayal of the American identity by building a wall to oppress the poor and keep them from the upward path -- and then begins to call the other side hateful things... When the other side tried to start an economic conversation.

This is just my interpretation of the situation.

Re:Amid debate, all 2016 American Nobel laureates are immigr... by croon on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @09:04AM (#12683961)
First off: Capitalism can't exist outside a system to help enforce that capitalism. All systems require tax to function. This is not appropriation of profits.

The tax code is complicated BECAUSE it was lobbied so that only the few have the resources to (ab)use it. If you think that a Trump in office would not act protectionist you are fooling yourself. I'm not saying Hillary in this matter would be any better.

The companies will stay as long as the US is a large market, because they need the presence.

Re: your comment that you couldn't edit in on walling off. If at first we take the literal part: [1].

On the economic part, undocumented workers have contributed 10% of the social security trust fund, while only being eligible for 1/15th of that in return, so that's a 14 to 1 net positive [2].

They (undocumented workers) also pay $11.64bn annually in state and local tax [3].

[1] http://foreignpolicy.com/2015/08/18/donald-trump-immigration...

[2] http://www.nytimes.com/2013/02/17/magazine/do-illegal-immigr...

[3] http://itep.org/itep_reports/2016/02/undocumented-immigrants...

Re:Amid debate, all 2016 American Nobel laureates are immigr... by punazj on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @10:09AM (#12684472)
Thanks for the articles, I'll read them when I get a chance.

I wasn't aware of those figures; rolling in my mind was that I'd read somewhere that immigrants took substantially more social benefits than natives (like 50% more, perhaps attributable to the culture). But I'm not sure if that was documented or undocumented or what, just a vague memory.

First reaction would be that anarcho-capitalism is a thing, albeit not a philosophy I think would possibly work (See Stefan Molyneux rambling on youtube).

I agree with your second point completely, the question is about the little guy. Neither of their policies would affect me much at all, so I feel it's my responsibility to vote for who I think would help the poor most.

Is the third one true? For example where I live in China there is a huge Apple advertising presence even with the 10-20% price increase versus USA prices. And with free trade, couldn't it be cheaper to be a "foreign" company without losing much presence / market share? I feel like tariffs are essential for forcing companies to stay to maintain market presence, instead of free trade deals.

Re:Amid debate, all 2016 American Nobel laureates are immigr... by eveningcoffee on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @07:50AM (#12683457)
It does not help if population of poor multiplies itself faster than the capital can crow or there are resources on Earth. :(

I think that it is foremost important thing to get the population gains under control. If this has happened then we have plenty of time of to figure out how to actually fairly share our home we call Earth.

Current trends do show that things are moving to towards normalization, but it is not yet conclusive.

Re:Amid debate, all 2016 American Nobel laureates are immigr... by speeder on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @09:32AM (#12684181)
Your idea is and old, and dangerous one.

Many countries trying to reduce population are succeeding, even Brazil that is not developed already has 1.8 child per woman on average. The problem is that the poor remain reproducing faster always.

So how you enforce it? Pull a China and remove rights of poor people that ended with multiple kids and end with murderous parents?

Murder children yourself, Sparta style?

Force sterilize women and then give out reproduction licenses like a dystopian scifi movie?

"Education" and "career" is not a solution, by definition the elite will have always more of that, and all else equal, will reproduce slower.

Re:Amid debate, all 2016 American Nobel laureates are immigr... by eveningcoffee on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @10:34AM (#12684713)
I think that, in principle if it could be arranged such that the exploitation of the children is not beneficial for the family then the problem would solve itself.

If children are only burden and not the source of the income (by direct workforce during the young age or by sending money to the family when older) and contraceptives are accepted and accessible then there is no initiative to have too many children. Well, at least it looks to be the case.

Re:Amid debate, all 2016 American Nobel laureates are immigr... by speeder on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @11:08AM (#12685063)
Then why families in Brazillian favelas, where children are a burden and government give free contraceptive and contraceptive education, still have extremely poor families with 6+ kids?
Re:Amid debate, all 2016 American Nobel laureates are immigr... by eveningcoffee on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @02:39PM (#12687292)
It is hard to say for me given that I am not very familiar with the situation. I met a guy who had a wife who were born in favelas. They do not live now in Brazil, just visit once a year. I do not know how much of it is factually correct, so please set me right if something of this is wrong.

First of he explained that Brazilian education system gets you trapped. While universities are free, the basic education is either expensive or so bad that it would not allow children to get into universities. So if you are born in favela, you can not get out of it based on your education. If this is like this by design and intentional, or just out of stupidity, I do not know. But I would conclude from this that also that there exists no social pressure in this community to get out of it as it is possibly regarded as almost impossible.

Second he explained that her wife went through serious hardship during the school age, as the school meal was for her only way to get something to eat. I would conclude from this that I could be that actually the children are not such a burden for parents in favelas - school system keeps them alive, they do not die from hunger and nobody gets blamed.

Third the average temperature in Rio is constantly >= 20 C. This means that nobody really has to prepare for prolonged period of cold. Nobody will die because they do not have proper housing or can not pay for the heating or have proper clothes.

Based on these 3 pieces of information I would the kids are for them not a burden, at least not in a sense I considered, in addition there is currently no force that would motivate to improve the situation.

So the solution would be more complicated. At least they are not motivated in children because of economical gains and it would possibly make the solution simpler.

PS. Please not the this is just an argumentation based on these small pieces of information. I would recommend to look up if there are some studies that would clarify this situation in a more systematic manner. Also I am certainly not claiming that this opinion piece reflects actual truth.

Re:Amid debate, all 2016 American Nobel laureates are immigr... by speeder on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @04:19PM (#12688170)
São Paulo right now, is having a problem of kids on schools not getting enough food.

Rio is just fucked up, the government right now is with a debt of about 500 million USD in unpaid wages to common state employees (teachers, cooks, janitors, etc...)

In some places, there are not even enough schools in first place.

Yet, people pump kids out like there is no tomorrow, I don't know why is that, people even make TV programs out of it, kinda like exploiting the poor by showing their bizareness on TV, like when they showed a family with 12 kids or something like that, where the older kids had to take care of newborns, and both parents combined and all welfare combined gave them in total about 300 USD month.

So how you put stop to that without resorting to extreme means? I know no viable solution.

All known plans toward that, ended being labelled as evil in some way (for example there are various theories that Swedish flu vaccines that caused diseases in young people were intentional culling of population, similarly many people believe that divorce laws, abortion, etc... is similarly some kind of evil plan to cull population).

Re:Amid debate, all 2016 American Nobel laureates are immigr... by eveningcoffee on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @06:09PM (#12688929)
Has there been any survey to figure out why is it like that? I think that it does not hurt and ask the questions from sizeable enough population sample to make some conclusions. Or is it avoided by some reason?

I know that Catholic Church has a lot of influence over South America, can this be related to this?

I think that it is actually very important to every individual on Earth to figure this out as more we have people on Earth the less can be shared among us and is there space for other species.

Re:Amid debate, all 2016 American Nobel laureates are immigr... by punazj on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @07:54AM (#12683485)
edit: it's not letting me edit.

As is apparent, I have a bit of a Trump tilt. I would actually really appreciate knowing more arguments against locked down borders in general (like Switzerland, say), besides social ones.

Re:Amid debate, all 2016 American Nobel laureates are immigr... by karmelapple on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @08:47AM (#12683828)
The Economist, a great publication, had an issue recently about why globalization gets a bum rap, although as with most of their pieces, there's plenty of nuance spelled out. Here is one of the many thoughtful articles from the issue [1].

1. http://www.economist.com/news/special-report/21707835-econom...

Re:Amid debate, all 2016 American Nobel laureates are immigr... by Joof on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @09:04AM (#12683958)
The majority of illegal immigrants are people who have overstayed their visas. A wall is expensive and won't stop them.